Good Players Could Mean Good 2009 Tide
Most observers of Alabama football are a good bit more casual than Crimson Tide Coach Nick Saban. But even coaches like to look at the tapes before making final determinations on performance.
Greg McElroy didn't play a perfect game, but the obvious conclusion is that he is far and away the leader at the quarterback position. As Saban said from start to finish, that shouldn't be a surprise because McElroy has more knowledge and more experience (though little game experience) in the offensive system.
McElroy looked more than merely most familiar with the system. He looked like potentially a big-time quarterback.
As has often been pointed out, quarterback success depends in great part how those around him play. The converse of that is that effective quarterback play can make things easier on those around him. Complete a few passes to Julio Jones, and the defensive front is likely to loosen up for a tailback.
No matter how good the quarterback, wide receivers and running backs are, though, the offensive line must perform. It is difficult to watch offensive linemen in a scrimmage unless you are the offensive line coach or the parent or girlfriend of the lineman. The one offensive lineman who was notable to the casual observer was center William Vlachos. It was not so much what Vlachos did as what defensive linemen didn't do against him.
Alabama's tailback situation will be better in the fall than it was Saturday. Put Mark Ingram, Roy Upchurch and Trent Richardson in the mix and things should pick up. Terry Grant impressed coaches in the spring. Ivan Matchett showed some good stuff in limited play.
Tight end play was very good by several players--Colin Peek, Preston Dial, Brad Smelley and Michael Williams all having eye-catching plays.
It was no surprise that Julio was the wide receiver of note. Mike McCoy also impressed. It would have been nice to have seen Marquis Maze working with McElroy. Maze had a good game, and it could have been excellent if he had made catches on a couple of passes that were just enough off the mark to be tough catches.
Maze had a couple of running plays that caught Alabama's defense off guard. That will happen occasionally, but isn't something to be greatly concerned about. Years ago legendary USC Coach John McKay was guest speaker at Alabama's coaching clinic. Following his lecture on defense, he was asked if the plan wasn't susceptible to a counter option. "You can't run a counter option every play," McKay said.
The list of defensive players who were impressive is a long one, and if Saban saw deficiencies that bodes well for how good it may be.
With Rashad Johnson gone, we spent more time than usual watching safeties and thought that two men who haven't been seen much looked very good. Robby Green, as Saban pointed out, got beat by McCoy on a touchdown play, but had an overall strong day. Mark Barron had a little playing time at safety as a true freshman and may be in for much more as a sophomore.
Linebackers look like an all-star unit, which is no surprise. Rolando McClain brings All-America credentials. Dont'a Hightower looks like a McClain clone.
Our vote for the Dwight Stephenson Award winner went to Marcel Dareus, but we were surprised others saw the same performance. Dareus won the award, which was voted by the media. His teammates have talked about his potential and he gave evidence of being a major factor on what appears to be an excellent defensive front.
The bottom line is that Alabama has a lot of very good football players. They have an off-season, then a fall camp under Saban and his staff to become a team. All-in-all, there is reason for optimistic anticipation for Sept. 5 and the GeorgiaDome season-opener against Virginia Tech.
BamaMag Top Stories
Looking At SEC Hot SeatsAlabama Coach Nick Saban isn’t on hot seat, but he’s inspired some
BamaMagFriday at 2:04 PM
Coach Speak: What Armour-Davis brings 'BamaAlabama got monster news on the recruiting trail Friday with the commitment of cornerback Jalyn Armour-Davis, who draws high praise from state champion coach Steve Mask.
BamaMagFriday at 12:31 PM
State's top defender Armour-Davis to AlabamaJalyn Armour-Davis had been back and fourth between Alabama, Auburn and Florida State this year but elected to go public between the three on Friday.
BamaMagFriday at 11:07 AM
'Bama Football Recruiting Q&A - 6/23Alabama has picked up a pair of commitments this month and plenty of top prospects will return to Tuscaloosa this summer. Some have made decisions to go elsewhere, to catch up on…
BamaMagFriday at 7:23 AM