Both Chiles and Burns are mobile quarterbacks that make play after play for their respective high schools.
Chiles has outstanding quickness, top end speed, and open field moves and vision. Burns is a bit bigger, not quite as fast, but has a tremendous arm and throws well on the run.
Chiles is good enough at quarterback that he could play the position for some teams on the next level, but he projects best at the wide receiver position. Most high school quarterbacks that are slotted to play another position on offense never get the chance to play that position until they get to college. Chiles is different. He has logged several snaps at wide receiver and wing back, and he shows that he is more than adept at catching the ball.
Once he has the ball in his hands, the fun really begins.
Burns is not quite the athlete, but he doesn't have to be, because of that big right arm. He reminds me a lot of Ryan Perrilloux, who was Scout.com's #1 Prospect in the South in the Class of
2005. He doesn't quite have the rocket arm that Perrilloux had, but he
shows better touch at the same stage.
Burns can hurt a team with his arm and his legs and is being recruited strictly as a quarterback.
Chiles is already committed to the Texas Longhorns, while Burns looks like he will decide between SEC Foes Arkansas and Auburn.
Which player is better? Depends on the need and the preference.
Burns is a player that will have the ball in his hands on every snap as a quarterback on the next level, so I'm inclined to lean towards the quarterback. It's hard to choose against a player like Chiles though who looks to be a weapon at receiver and would be dynamite as a return man.
As a College Scout, the decision would be easy... Offer them Both!
Who do you like better? Be the Scout, and Come Talk about it on the Scout.com Recruiting Message Board
See each in action in this presentation by ScoutTV*:
#5 QB Kodi Burns
#12 ATH John Chiles
*ScoutTV is free for Total Access Pass Subscribers. For a limited time, a Full Year of Sports Illustrated is included with your Annual Purchase. So, there has never been a better time to sign up for a Scout.com Total Access Pass. Give us a Try For 7 Days, you won't regret it.
Just Click the Link and Choose your School to get started: