Cougar Secondary has a Chip on Its Shoulder

It is no secret that BYU's defensive backs struggled last season. By their own admission, they were the weakest part of the team. The group has taken a beating from fans and media, but the much maligned safeties and cornerbacks are fed up with it and determined to prove that things have changed.

"I'm so sick of it," said cornerback Kayle Buchanan. "Nobody likes to be the weak link on any team and we all know that we were the weak link last year. Nobody wants to be that, so yeah, I have a huge chip on my shoulder heading into this season. I think we all do. Things need to change and I think they are changing."

The numbers were not pretty for last year's defensive backs. They surrendered over 269 yards through the air and 25 passing touchdowns. Opposing teams threw for a 7.9-yard per pass average and 12.5 yards per reception, which surpassed the mark set by BYU's own prolific offense.

"It has to change," said starting safety Quinn Gooch about the secondary's performance of last year. "We put in an entire new scheme to address it, got a new coach, basically did everything to change it. Now it's just up to us. It's all on us."


The obvious change this year came with the new 3-4 zone-heavy scheme that new cornerbacks coach Jaime Hill is directing. It is a scheme that coaches felt could best serve the talent BYU currently has and typically gets at the defensive back position. So far, the returns have been positive in practice.

"The secondary is definitely better," said quarterback John Beck who is perhaps the foremost authority on the strengths and weaknesses of BYU's defensive backfield due to the volume of reps he took against them in fall camp. "They're more confident in their coverages, and it's been tougher this year going against them. They've definitely improved and hopefully that shows up this season starting against Arizona. It think it will."

The defensive backs certainly feel that the move to a more conventional coverage scheme has translated into improved practice play. The safeties and cornerbacks have less to worry about in the new defense, and that suits them just fine.

"It's not like we have to do 4 or 5 different things back there with every play," said Gooch. "It's a lot more simple than it has been, especially for us [safeties]. In the past we weren't really safeties because we did everything that linebackers do. Now we're just doing what most safeties do in providing over-the-top coverages. We still might blitz and do other stuff, sure, but it's a lot more simplified. I have a lot of confidence in what we're doing, and we'll see what becomes of it this Saturday."

Criddle to Help Out

One of the more significant depth chart movements this fall has been walk-on Ben Criddle taking over the starting boundary cornerback duties from Kayle Buchanan. While Buchanan is still battling through nagging injuries, Criddle is ready to step up and play as he promised head coach Bronco Mendenhall a year ago.

"I told Coach Mendenhall when we first met that I would start and be an all-MWC cornerback for him," said Criddle. "I still believe that is what will happen. I have a lot of confidence, and I'm ready to have a great year."

Several of Criddle's teammates have noticed how he was the cornerback's most consistent performer in fall camp. He was solid in both run support and pass coverage.

"Ben Criddle wears those ankle braces, but don't let that fool you," said Gooch. "He's a very good player and very fast. He's helped us a lot in practice, and he's going to help us a lot this year. We all have a lot of confidence in him."

"We play the same position," said Buchanan, "I'm battling him for a spot sort of, but I seriously want coaches to do what is best for the team. If I'm starting and not getting it done, then I want Criddle in there. It's not about me, we're a team. I just want us not to get embarrassed again. I feel that I can help with that, and I feel that Ben can as well."

If Criddle pulls through with his all-Mountain West prognostication, it should be a good sign for the Cougar secondary.

"I don't know of too many bad secondaries that have first-team all-Conference players on it," said Criddle. "That's my goal, and if I do that then it will mean that we're getting it done covering guys and lending good run support throughout the year."

So the cards are on the table. The BYU secondary has a new system, a new coach, and, perhaps most importantly, a new confidence. Of course, none of it means anything if they cannot get it done on the field starting with the game against Arizona this Saturday.

"I guess we'll see, won't we?" asked Gooch about how he and his teammates will fare against the Wildcats. "We've put a lot of work in, but none of it matters if we can't get it done on the field. We have confidence that we will, but we'll see this Saturday if we're ready to step up and not be the weak link on this team anymore."


Get one year of Sports Illustrated magazine when you subscribe or upgrade to a annual Total Access Pass.

For a limited time any non-subscriber who signs up for a new annual Total Access Pass subscription, OR any monthly subscriber who upgrades to an annual Total Access Pass will also receive a one-year subscription (56 issues) to Sports Illustrated (a $39.95 value) and a $15 gift certificate to This is an incredible offer!!

Again, here's what you get:

  • One year of access to and the entire network
  • One year (10 issues) of Total Blue Sports Magazine
  • One year of Sports Illustrated
  • $15 to use on

Click here to sign up on-line: Subscribe Securely Online,

Or call our customer service center at 888-501-5752 and ask how you can subscribe or upgrade to this terrific package.


For more on this offer click on the following link:

TBS-SI Offer Explanation.

Total Blue Sports Top Stories