Remember When? The Catch II

Next to Jerry Butler's "The Catch" that lifted Clemson to a 31-27 win in 1977, Rod Gardner's 50-yard reception on a frigid evening in Death Valley might be the biggest play in the history of the 104-year old rivalry.

Flashback: Clemson vs. South Carolina
November 18, 2000
Tigers 16, Gamecocks 14

Gardner's catch of Woodrow Dantzler's pass setup Aaron Hunt's 25-yard field goal with three seconds left to lift 16th-ranked Clemson to an improbable 16-14 victory over No. 25 South Carolina. To the Tiger faithful, the 50-yard catch will always be known as "The Catch II."

To South Carolina fans it will always be known as "The Push off."

Regardless, of what the 85,500 fans in Death Valley or the millions on television at home called it – the November 18, 2000 match up was a classic.

The Tigers entered the game struggling after taking back-to-back defeats to Georgia Tech and Florida State into an off-week. Tommy Bowden's second Clemson team started the year 8-0 and peaked at No. 3 in the USA Today/ESPN Coaches' poll before the two defeats. USC was also coming of a loss, its to Florida, but the Gamecocks were riding high with a 7-3 record under head coach Lou Holtz. It was an unbelievable mark considering the team was not even a year removed from its 0-11 record the year before.

It appeared South Carolina had did the unthinkable and beat the Tigers when tight end Tommy Hill fell on a Derek Watson fumble in the Clemson end zone with 59 second left. The recovery gave the Gamecocks a 14-13 lead and left the few thousands jubilant USC supporters in the stands cheering while the rest of the stadium stood shocked at what they had just seen.

But Hill's fumble recovery was the beginning of the jaw-dropping moments.

"I knew I had to make a play to win the game," Gardner told The State newspaper after the game. "We didn't want to lose the last game like that." Clemson took the ensuing kickoff and moved the ball out to its own 42-yard line when it called a timeout with 19 seconds left and facing a third down-and-12. When the Tigers came out of the timeout, Dantzler rolled to his left and then threw deep to Gardner, who was running a go route down the right sideline.

South Carolina had cornerback Andre Goodman trailing Gardner underneath and safety Deandre Eiland over the top. But Dantzler's roll to his left brought Eiland up just enough to where it came down to Goodman with single coverage on Gardner.

As the ball approached the two, both tussled with each other until Gardner extended his left arm to create separation from Goodman just before leaping up to snatch the Dantzler aerial and falling backwards at the USC 8-yard line.

"It was in slow motion," Gardner said. "I wasn't even thinking about the defender. I just knew I had to make a play. And when it dropped in my hands, oh man."

It was the second straight year the 6-foot-3 wide receiver broke the hearts of the Gamecocks. In 1999, he snatched a 29-yard touchdown pass on fourth down late to seal a 31-21 Clemson victory. "I was looking for one-on-one (coverage)," Gardner said. "I didn't touch him. I was playing the ball."

Goodman had a different view.

"I looked at the ref and I knew he was going to pull the flag," he said. "He looked at me and smiled. I said, ‘You had to see that.' He just smiled and shook his head.

"That rule is so funny. Sometimes it's called and sometimes it isn't."

And it wasn't as Hunt's field goal lifted the Tigers to its fourth straight victory over the Gamecocks and started a debate that still lives on today.

"I'm still trying to figure out what happened," Dantzler said. Top Stories