Essence Carson added 18 for the Scarlet Knights (20-8), who made their fourth consecutive Big East semifinals. They will play either Pittsburgh or Marquette on Monday night.
Rutgers used a 13-2 second-half run to turn a 42-40 deficit into a 53-44 lead and held off the Blue Demons the rest of the way.
"Veteran players hit clutch shots," Scarlet Knights coach C. Vivian Stringer said of the run. "That's what it's all about. Everybody can talk, 'I can do this and that' when it doesn't count ... but when you put your life on the line, it becomes another issue."
Both teams started slowly. DePaul hit just one of its first five shots and Rutgers was 2-for-8 from the field. The teams combined for seven turnovers in the first five minutes, and the game was tied 5-5.
The Blue Demons' 3-point shooting kept them in the game. They were 7-of-14 from behind the arc in the first half and used consecutive 3-pointers from Caprice Smith, Jenna Rubino and Missy Mitidiero to turn a 27-26 deficit into a 32-28 halftime lead.
But they hit just 2-of-12 from 3-point range after the break.
"When we stopped letting the dribble penetration and let them come open, and started contesting all the threes, it worked to our benefit," Carson said.
Mitidiero led four Blue Demons (19-12) in double figures with 14 points. Smith and Allie Quigley had 11 and Rubino added 10.
The Blue Demons finished the game with 25 turnovers, 16 in the first half. The Scarlet Knights were only slightly better with 22 total turnovers, 14 in the first half.
"If we could have a four-point lead at halftime with 16 turnovers, I thought we'd have a chance if we could just eliminate our turnovers and get some kind of offensive flow and continue to defend in the second half," DePaul coach Doug Bruno said. "We did not get that offensive flow, and that's because Rutgers kept us from getting it."
DePaul came in averaging eight 3-pointers and 21 attempts per game. Quigley, who scored 28 points in a first-round win over Notre Dame, was 0-for-7 from beyond the arc.
Kia Vaughn, who averages 13 points per game for Rutgers, was in foul trouble throughout and finished with four points and four rebounds.
DePaul freshman point guard China Threatt took a knee to her right eye with 15:10 left in the first half, opening a cut that kept her out of the game for 10 minutes while she received three stitches.
DePaul had won five of its last seven games coming in, and had defeated Rutgers 87-73 in their only regular-season meeting on Dec. 7.
Postgame Notes: Allie Quigley became the first player in school history with at least 1,300 career points, 300 assists and 150 three-pointers… Caprice Smith registered her 10th career double-double… the Blue Demons are now 13-2 this season when holding opponents to less than 70 points… at least four players have scored in double-figures in 16 games this season… Rutgers leads the series, 2-1… Sunday was the first postseason meeting between the two programs.
Official Box Score
DePaul Falls in Big East Quarterfinals
We Are DePaul Top Stories
No. 19 DePaul Women Upset in OvertimeCHICAGO - For two teams that average 160 points per game between them, 203 points was more expected than unexpected.
We Are DePaulSaturday at 9:09 PM
DePaul loses heartbreaker in overtimeIt was heartbreak city for the Blue Demons in a 70-69 overtime loss to 13th ranked Butler at Allstate Arena on Saturday afternoon.
We Are DePaulSaturday at 2:32 PM
St. John's storms past DePaulDePaul once again did not bring a full 40-minute effort and the end result was a 78-68 loss to St. John's Monday afternoon at Carnesecca Arena during the Big East's annual marathon…
We Are DePaul01/17/2017
Schulte, DePaul Zap XavierCHICAGO - One of the few things DePaul’s Brooke Schulte did wrong Sunday afternoon was shoot 0-2 from three-point range. The rest of her game was on target.
We Are DePaul01/15/2017
Coleman, DePaul Buzz ButlerCHICAGO- DePaul's Amarah Coleman scored a career-high 20 points Friday night versus Butler, but it was one of her single digit statistics that meant the most to her and to her…
We Are DePaul01/14/2017