Five reasons Tide, Irish will win title game

Our Alabama and Notre Dame publishers give you five reasons why each team will win the BCS title.

BCS National Championship

No. 1 Notre Dame vs. No. 2 Alabama
Monday, 8 p.m. ET (in Miami)
CFN's BCS title game preview

Notre Dame Fighting Irish

By Tim O'Malley,

Five reasons Notre Dame will win

The Irish are fundamentally sound

Alabama's balanced offense has faced athletic, explosive defenses in 2012, including one each day in practice. But one of football's lost arts can be found in spades on the defensive side of scrimmage in South Bend -- Notre Dame has the best tackling defense in the nation. Crimson Tide running backs Eddie Lacy and T.J. Yeldon won't continually break free as they did against sloppy Georgia in the SEC Championship game.

Alabama's best player will endure his toughest outing

Crimson Tide center Barrett Jones is a master of his craft, and the most versatile, cerebral technician in the college game. Monday night in Miami, Jones will square off against Notre Dame's second-best football player, junior nose guard Louis Nix, the gregarious behemoth inexplicably snubbed by most post-season All-America teams. Nix's blend of raw power and short space quickness won't be unique to Jones -- his gap discipline working in congress with that skillset will. Look for Notre Dame to win the battle of the middle, a rarity vs. Bama's best.

Don't forget about Everett Golson and Notre Dame's offense ... they can hurt you too.

Long road to hoe

From the first game in Dublin, Ireland, through Game 12 in Los Angeles, Notre Dame's opponents began nearly 120 offensive series 60 or more yards away from the Irish goal. Only two of those drives ended in touchdowns. Defensive coordinator Bob Diaco's long-stated goal to "minimize points" was realized in 2012 as the Irish defense surrendered just nine touchdowns, only one of which occurred from beyond 15 yards away, and just one surrendered against four ranked teams. The Irish occasionally concede yardage but have consistently found a way to force a punt, field goal or a turnover as an end result.

60-minute men

Once, they drove downfield for the winning score. Two more times they prevailed in overtime, in both instances after knotting the score late. On four other occasions, Notre Dame's "other" unit ensured victory with time-consuming marches through the heart of the opponent's defense. The defense rightfully receives ample credit for Notre Dame's No. 1 ranking, but an improved, methodical, and now versatile Irish offense won all seven fourth quarter battles it faced in the team's seven tight contests of 2012. Alabama wins close games by breaking an opponent's will -- that's not yet proven possible vs. Brian Kelly's Irish.

Heart (and head) of a champion


Want more on the Fighting Irish? Get full team and recruiting coverage and much more at

An unlikely game-winning drive by the backup quarterback. A pair of inspired, violent goal line stands. An opponent's chip-shot field goal that sailed wide and a penalty vs. the Irish overlooked in the process. A 14-point fourth quarter deficit overcome. Four overtimes played without a touchdown allowed.

These are the unlikely highlights of Notre Dame's journey, but the myriad plays intertwined better define Kelly's crew. They're methodical and balanced offensively, consistent and disciplined defensively, and singular in overall focus, the latter a mission to find a way to win each week, one game at a time.

That fits this winner-take-all scenario perfectly.

Alabama Crimson Tide

By Kirk McNair,

Five reasons Alabama will win

Strong offensive line

For as long as they have been playing football, the team with the best offensive line almost always wins. Alabama has three offensive linemen who have been named first team All-America on various teams this year, including 2011 Outland Trophy nd 2012 Rimington Award winner Barrett Jones. And Alabama Coach Nick Saban said the two who didn't get All-America were just as good but fell victim to the limit on number who could be nominated from one team.

Did I just mention Nick Saban?

Even when you get past Eddie Lacy, there's T.J. Yeldon waiting in the wings.

Who among us does not consider him the best coach in college football, among the best of all-time? He has already won three BCS National Championships, two at Alabama, one as recently as last year. Saban has the intellect, the work ethic, and the experience of successfully preparing a team for a national championship game.

What rebuilding year?

This was considered a rebuilding year for the Alabama defense, which lost six players to the NFL draft, including three first-round choices. How did the Crimson Tide respond? Alabama leads the nation in total defense and rushing defense, ranks second in scoring defense, sixth in pass defense, second in red zone defense, and first in fewest first downs allowed. Not too shabby for a rebuilding year.

Two-headed monster at RB

Just about the time an opposing defense has decided it doesn't want to see any more of 230-pound junior tailback Eddie Lacy (184 carries, 1,182 yards, 6.4 ypc, 16 TDs), along comes 220-pound freshman tailback T.J. Yeldon (154 carries, 1,000 yards, 6.5 ypc, 11 TDs). Both rank in the top 10 among SEC rushers. It is the first time in Alabama history the Crimson Tide have had two 1,000-yard rushers.


Want more on the Crimson Tide? Get full team and recruiting coverage and much more at

But you have to have balance

Alabama has gained 2,920 yards rushing and 2,788 yards passing. 'Bama quarterback A.J. McCarron leads the nation in passing efficiency with his 191-286 (66.8 percent) for 2,669 yards and a school record 26 touchdowns against only three interceptions. McCarron has been Alabama's starting quarterback for two years, has a record of 24-2, has won both an SEC and a national championship, and was MVP of last year's BCS National Championship Game.

Scout CFB Top Stories