Wolverines quarterback Denard Robinson left the game late in the first half with a right elbow injury. Robinson, who spent the second half on the sideline in an overcoat, watched as freshman backup Russell Bellomy threw three interceptions.
The Huskers (6-2, 3-1) moved into a first-place tie with Michigan in the Legends but own the tiebreaker.
Michigan (5-3, 3-1) generated a season-low 188 yards during its first visit to Memorial Stadium since 1911. The Wolverines had 52 in the second half.
"This was a big step for us," Nebraska coach Bo Pelini said. "Just like I told the team, you win and the season goes on and it takes you higher and higher."
Asked about being in the driver's seat in the division heading into the next game at Michigan State, Pelini said, "I don't buy into any of that."
It was the second straight game Michigan failed to score a touchdown.
"When you count on field goals and get into the red zone and don't score (touchdowns), that will hurt you in a big game. That's what happened," Michigan coach Brady Hoke said.
Taylor Martinez was 14 of 24 for 166 yards, with an interception for the Huskers. Bellomy was 3 of 16 for 38 yards.
Robinson has accounted for two-thirds of Michigan's offensive production this season, and the Wolverines were lost without him. Hoke said Robinson aggravated a nerve injury in his right elbow when he was tackled at the Nebraska 8 late in the first half.
"When he hit it, he hit it the wrong way," Hoke said.
Hoke gave no additional details on Robinson's status.
Bellomy was off target on his first 10 passes, and two of his interceptions resulted in 10 Nebraska points. Daimion Stafford picked off his underthrown ball early in the fourth to set up Abdullah's 12-yard touchdown run for a 23-9 lead.
Abdullah, filling in for the injured Rex Burkhead, went over 100 yards for the fourth time this season.
"In the second half, especially late in the third quarter, we didn't tackle well as a defense," Hoke said. "When you don't tackle well in a big game, it doesn't go well."
Brett Maher kicked field goals of 19, 51 and 31 yards, with his last one putting Nebraska up 16-6 in the third quarter.
Michigan got within 16-9 late in the third quarter on Brenan Gibbons' 38-yard field goal. The Wolverines moved 58 yards on the series, but 45 of them were the result of Nebraska penalties.
Josh Mitchell was called for a high hit on Roy Roundtree, the Nebraska bench was flagged for unsportsmanlike conduct and Andrew Green interfered with Roundtree on a pass to the end zone.
The Huskers were penalized eight times for 104 yards.
Nebraska led 7-6 after a defense-dominated first half.
The Huskers broke through for a touchdown early in the second quarter, with Martinez needing only a couple minutes to move his team 72 yards. Nebraska had netted just 8 rushing yards on its first six runs, so offensive coordinator Tim Beck called on Martinez to pass on five of the six plays.
He hit Ben Cotton for 15 yards, Jamal Turner for 12, Quincy Enunwa for 5 and Stephen Osborne for 19 before going downfield to Kenny Bell. Bell almost stopped while waiting for the ball to arrive along the sideline, then he turned and dived for the pylon to finish the 32-yard touchdown.
Gibbons finished the next two Michigan drives with field goals of 52 and 24 yards to make it a one-point game.
Robinson ran for 46 yards on 10 carries and completed 6 of 11 passes for 55 yards before he got hurt.
The game was billed as the second meeting ever between quarterbacks who each have 5,000 yards passing and 2,000 yards rushing in their careers. The first such game matched Texas' Vince Young against Missouri's Brad Smith in 2005.
The Huskers have won 11 straight night games at Memorial Stadium and are 37-5 under the lights in Lincoln since 1986.
Nebraska commemorated the 50th anniversary of its NCAA-record sellout streak. Saturday's game was the 323rd in a row.
U-M loses QB Robinson in upset loss @Nebraska
The Michigan Insider Top Stories
Webblog: Samuels "feeling good" about U-MLos Lunas (N.M.) RB O'Maury Samuels came went to his official visit to Michigan this weekend with a primary objective. The Wolverine coaching staff made sure he achieved it.
The Michigan InsiderYesterday at 2:37 PM
WATCH: Irvin reacts to victory over IllinoisWatch as senior captain Zak Irvin reacts to Michigan's 66-57 victory over Illinois.
The Michigan InsiderSaturday at 2:17 PM
RECAP: U-M with statement win against IlliniTMI's Josh Newkirk and Josh Henschke recap Michigan's 66-57 statement win against Illinois and more.
The Michigan InsiderSaturday at 2:14 PM
What we learned: U-M beats Illinois 66-57The Michigan Insider breaks down what it learned during Michigan's 66-57 victory over Illinois on Saturday.
The Michigan InsiderSaturday at 12:35 PM
Scout's Top 25 Recruitng ClassesA look at Scout's top 25 classes with just over a week to go to Signing Day.
Scout FootballSaturday at 9:02 AM