History Sides With Buckeyes Vs. Penn State

Momentum might currently be on Penn State's side but history will definitely be with Ohio State when the two Big Ten rivals collide tomorrow. See what we mean along with the regular weekly features as well as the Fearless Forecast predicting a huge Upset Special in the SEC.

It is always a source of amusement and bemusement to visit college football message boards and watch while fans rationalize their favorite team's shortcomings.

Case in point: Penn State fans took particular exception to longtime Cleveland Plain Dealer columnist Bill Livingston's piece on Wednesday that compared the independent Penn State teams of the 1970s and '80s to Boise States and TCUs of today.

You can ready the column for yourself but the gist of what Livingston wrote was that the pre-Big Ten Nittany Lions feasted on lesser opponents and padded their yearly records on soft schedules – the same knock Boise State and TCU face these days when trying to elbow their way into the national championship picture.

To say Nittany Lions fans disagreed with Livingston would be a gross understatement, which is fine in the overall scheme of things. After all, doesn't almost everyone come to the defense of their favorite team? Where the Blue and White faithful lost me, though, was when they insisted their team would have competed for plenty of Big Ten championships throughout the 1970s and 1980s when Ohio State and Michigan won or shared 17 of the 20 league titles.

As the late U.S. Sen. Daniel Patrick Moynihan once stated, "Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not his own facts."

First of all, if Penn State would have contended for all of those championships before joining the conference, why don't the Nittany Lions have more Big Ten titles than the one outright championship they won in 1994 and the two crowns they shared in 2005 and 2008? Why have they had at least three league losses in 10 of their 17 previous seasons as a conference member?

Read the rest by clicking on this link: Rea's Say: Nov. 12.


Buckeye Sports Top Stories