This past season he hit 40 of 41 PATs (97.56 percent) and seven of 11 field goals with a long of 47 yards. He also booted 48 punts for an average of 39 yards this year.
Wagner has received a myriad of honors, including being selected to the Pennsylvania Big 33 squad, elected to Pennsylvania Big 33 Team, Pennsylvania Football News Class AAAA first-team All-State at punter, Harrisburg Patriot-News Platinum 33 Team at kicker, Associated Press Pennsylvania Class AAAA first-team All-State at punter, and first-team place-kicker Mid-Penn Conference.
Wagner also finished tied for third overall among college and high school kickers at the 4th Down Sports Elite Competition Camp and was rated a 4 Star (highest rating) in kickoffs at the Scout.com Kicking Combine.
Wagner attended Penn State's football camp and placed second overall in the kickoff distance competition.