Recruiting rankings have always been more art than science. But it's also always a positive for fans of recruiting when the Cougs haul in the four-star and three-star guys. And the numbers are the numbers.
This year's early haul, so far, isn't rated as highly as was last year's.
The first five verbal commits of last year averaged out to a 3.4 star ranking (Thomas Toki, Tyler Hilinski, Kameron Powell, James Williams, Aaron Porter).
Four of seven of this year's pledges are rated two stars by Scout.com. The other three are three-star prospects. The average: a 2.4 star ranking (Ian Book, Jihad Woods, Jalen Thompson, Renard Bell, Stephen Houston, D'Jimon Jones, Josiah Westbrook).
Two points to mention: rankings can be heavily weighted on the camp and combine circuit. Houston, for example, didn't attend the Las Vegas 7v7. If he had and performed well, he might not be two stars.
Second, Mike Leach and his assistant coaches don't care about star ratings. They rely on their own evaluation process.
The evidence points to Leach being pretty good in that area. As one example, the Cougs' last class was raided in the final weeks before Signing Day. Schools that hadn't offered when the prospect pledged WSU did so by the end.
Still, there is a lack of other Pac-12 offers when it comes to the Cougs' seven pledges in this class. The only one with another Pac-12 offer is Thompson, whom the Huskies offered.
An optimist might counter that Leach has gotten more pledges from diamond in the rough types early on, that he may also have landed them before other Pac-12 schools got around to offering and that many of the three- and four-star types who hold other Pac-12 offers will pledge crimson down the road in this class.
Are you an optimist or a pessimist when it comes to the star rankings of the 2016 WSU recruiting class? There's video to help you determine how good an early crop you think the Cougs have on board.
QB Ian Book (pictured above)
LB Jihad Woods
WR/CB Renard Bell
CB Jalen Thompson
WR Stephen Houston
WR/CB D'Jimon Jones
WR Josiah Wetbrook
Comparing early WSU pledges to '15 crop
Cougfan Top Stories
CouGreat Erik Coleman analyzes 2016 CougsLET’S GET DOWN to brass tacks with Washington State’s Pac-12 opener just 48 hours away. Where are the Cougs at right now? If you are who you are on the field on Saturdays, a great…
Recruiting: WSU 3-star LB target sets dateWASHINGTON STATE 3-star linebacker target Faavae Faavae out of Santa Ana, Calif., is one of the top linebacker prospects in the West, according to Scout.com National Analyst Greg…
Scout Football11:30 AM
New WSU anthracite helmets debut SaturdayOUR FRIENDS DOWN in Eugene aren't the only ones who break out new stuff on game day. The Cougar Equipment twitter handle posted pictures of the new anthracite helmets the Cougs…
CF.C podcast: 5 WSU questions w/ Loh & ThorpeEACH WEEK for the remainder of the football season, Cougfan.com will check in with the beat writers who cover Cougar football for The Spokesman-Review and The Seattle Times; Jacob…