1. Aaron Hill - SS:Hill, the 13th overall pick in the 2003 draft, is a patient hitter with solid pop who could shift to third depending on the speed of his progress. He is a high-ceiling player whose solid showing in New Hampshire raised his stock to that of an elite middle infield prospect. Hill will likely begin the 2005 season with Triple-A Syracuse, and stay there the entire season before he makes a profound impact in 2006.
2. Josh Banks - RHP: Banks is a promising young pitcher who relies on his above-average fastball, a terrific slider and a splitter to get through innings. Banks showed the
mental toughness needed to pitch in the major leagues last season: he struggled upon arriving at Double-A New Hampshire after a mid-season
promotion, but rallied and finished the season strong. Banks is a promising right-hander who should have been drafted in the first round two years ago if it was not for a blister problem. Some might think ranking him second is very friendly, however, we expect Josh to be a successful major league pitcher starting in 2006.
3. Brandon League - RHP: Many would like to see the Jays use League as a starter, however, his best chance for success will be to pitch out of the bullpen. After drafting him
out of Hawaii, the Jays used League as a starter so he could get mound experience and accumulate more innings in order to have him use his entire
repertoire and mature faster. We believe League will be an effective bullpen arm, however, we are bothered by the fact that his K/9 IP ratio is not higher. With his blazing fastball and slider, League should be striking out more batters, especially in the minor leagues.
4. Guillermo Quiroz -C : Quiroz is a sound defensive catcher who finally found his stroke in 2003. He was derailed by a broken hand in 2004, which sets his estimated time of
arrival back to middle to late 2005. Quiroz does not project to be a high average hitter, but he should possess twenty-home-run ability and a fine presence behind the plate.
5. Dustin McGowan - RHP: If not for Tommy John surgery McGowan would have been ranked number one. The tall right hander has the potential to be a dominant power pitcher. The
recovery from Tommy John surgery delays his estimated time of arrival by half a season or so, but if his velocity returns he could very well be the next Jays ace. The organization will be careful with McGowan in 2005, but many of the club's executives feel he will be back in form towards the latter half of the season.
6. Francisco Rosario - RHP: Rosario is somewhat of an enigma. He has battled injuries and inconsistencies throughout his young career. His K/9 IP of 8.4 at New Hampshire last year is indicative of his stuff, yet so is his rather high ERA (4.31). The Jays are high on Rosario, but he needs to find the rhythm in
his game. Rosario was coming back from Tommy John surgery in 2004, which could be an explanation for his struggles, however, he is beginning to receive the label of injury prone as he suffers nagging injuries at times. A move to the bullpen could be in his future.
7. Shaun Marcum - RHP: Marcum began the 2004 season with Charleston and posted a K/9 IP ratio of
9.45 and a B/9 IP ratio of 1.82. Playing at an age of 22, many thought
Marcum was just too mature for the South Atlantic League, and when he earned
the promotion to the Florida State League those people expected his demise.
However, Marcum posted a better ERA, and even more impressive were his K/9
IP and B/9 IP ratios. Marcum allowed 0.52 walks per nine innings, while
striking out 8.75 batters per nine innings, and solidified his place in the
top 10. Marcum features an above-average fastball and slider, and even more
impressive would be the fact that he began pitching just several years ago,
as he was originally a college shortstop.
8. Russ Adams - SS: J.P. Ricciardi's first ever draft pick, Adams is a player know more for
his intangibles than what he actually produces. Adams is believed to be only
average defensively and to possess little power. Adams does have nice speed,
which could translate into twenty stolen bases at the major league level,
and he has a good eye at the plate, sprays hits to all fields and shows a
lot of hustle.
9. David Purcey - LHP: Purcey was the Jays' first-round pick in 2004. Purcey features an excellent
fastball to go along with his dominating curveball, but must overcome some
mechanical issues as he begins to pitch in professional baseball. The sky is
the limit for this left-hander, however, with the proper adjustments in his
delivery, Purcey could be in the Jays' rotation within two years.
10. Gabe Gross - OF: A former top draft choice of the Jays, Gross has not fully lived up to his
potential, however, one thing to notice is Gross has done an excellent job
adjusting to each new level he saw the following season. It does not appear
Gross will turn into the big time power hitter the Jays originally thought
he would become, but with his defensive skills and his plate discipline,
Gross figures to battle for a chance at the everyday left field spot in
11. Gustavo Chacin - RHP: His talent is not as great as some of the other prospects, but his poise and
control might be his ticket to the majors. A bit of a late-bloomer, Chacin
prevailed in the minors last season and sparkled in his two-start audition
in the majors. Chacin is a lefty who tops out in the low 90s but has
displayed pinpoint control in the minors. Chacin would have been ranked
higher, however, we are not completely sold on him. We would like for him to
duplicate his success for a second consecutive season, and also show the
ability to dominate hitters more in the minor leagues.
12. Zach Jackson - LHP: Jackson was selected in the supplemental round of the 2004 draft. He pitches
well beyond his age and his ability to pitch inside shows fearlessness, and
could result in him thriving at higher levels. He has three above-average
pitches and shows solid command.
13. Curtis Thigpen - C: Thigpen sparkled in his professional debut batting .301 with seven home runs
with the Auburn Doubledays, however, we see a future position switch in the
future for Thigpen. The Jays have several catchers that are solid
offensively and defensively, and Thigpen's best tool is clearly his bat.
It would not make sense for the Jays to keep the athletic Thigpen and his
powerful bat behind the plate, when he could thrive at another position.
14. Jamie Vermilyea -RHP: The owner of a perfect game at Double-A has surprised many scouts with his
progress. He does not throw hard by any means but uses his slider
effectively and is developing a cutter. Like Chacin, his K/IP numbers are
not great, and the Jays believe Vermilyea will be best suited for the
bullpen. His command and versatility will increase his success at the major
league level, even if it means pitching out of the pen.
15. John Hattig Jr. - 3B: Obtained from the Red Sox in the Terry Adams trade, Hattig is a
switch-hitting 3B with power and a good eye. If Hattig is to have a future
in the majors, we see it at first base rather than third base. The biggest
question will be if Hattig can translate his power numbers to justify
playing first base on an everyday basis. Regardless, this was a very good
trade for the Jays, and at the very least the Jays have a power bat off the
16. Adam Lind - OF: Raw is the operative word with Adam. Lind can flat out mash the ball. Lind
is a left-handed hitter with a quick swing and he uses all fields to his
advantage. In his brief time in professional baseball, Lind has shown
excellent bat control, and proven he can handle the adjustment to the wooden
bats well, and maintain his power threat. Look for Lind to have another
fabulous 2005 minor league season. He could very well be in the top 10 this
time next season.
17. Yuber Rodriguez - OF: Rodriguez did it all during the 2004 season while playing for Pulaski in the
Appalachian League. He demonstrated extra-base power as he hit twelve
doubles, six triples and eight home runs, and we believe he will maintain
his power production in the higher levels. He showed his speed on the base
paths stealing nine bases in twelve attempts, and rounded out his tools by
playing a fabulous center field. Rodriguez is young, and will be an exciting
player for the fans to follow in his journey to the major leagues.
18. Ismael Ramirez -RHP: Ramirez's dominance over his last dozen starts last season shows the
heights which this prospect might be able to reach. This right-hander's
2.72 ERA in 165 innings in high-A is very encouraging as was his 1.06 WHIP.
At twenty-four years old, Ramirez will need to accelerate his progress in
2005 and dazzle at Double-A if he wants to be considered as a true elite
19. John-Ford Griffin -OF: Griffin has not progressed as many expected when Ricciardi obtained him from
Oakland. Griffin battled injuries last year, and also started the season in
a slump by hitting .230 in May. He is twenty-five years old, so the time
for him to produce his now. He does have the power to get a major league
look in the near future.
20. Vince Perkins -RHP: This Canadian has good power but some serious control problems, and he needs
to cut down his walks if he is to be taken more seriously. His
fastball/slider combination could be successful in the majors, but only if
he can find the plate. At twenty-three, Perkins is still relatively young, and with
his type of arm, he will be given every chance to succeed in the major
21. Vito Chiaravalloti - 1B: The 15th round pick of the Jays in 2003 has exceeded many expectations. The
Jays lack a surplus of promising bats, so the athletic first baseman might
find an opportunity sooner rather than later. Chiaravalotti is a big guy,
with a long last name, who displays much power and bat speed. His
willingness to use the opposite field shows his maturity.
22. Robinson Diaz - C: After playing in Pulaski during the 2003 season, Diaz was promoted to low-A
last year and made himself an All-Star. Diaz completes the Jays' troika of
talented backstops. Much like Thigpen, he displays a promising bat with
good power, but must learn to walk more and needs to refine his defense --
outside of his strong arm. His overall hitting looks extremely solid at
this point of his young career.
23. Raul Tablado -3B: Tablado finally turned his promise into production last year in high-A. His
.300/.351/.582 line suggests he could have a very promising future if he
controls his temper and continues honing his skills. Look for him to climb
the prospects lists in the next couple of years.
24. Rob Cosby -3B: Cosby came into 2004 ready for a breakout season, however, it was a lost
year for him as he was hurt five games into the season and did not play
again. He has shown over the course of his minor league career that he has
some skill, as his OBP has risen steadily over the past few seasons. He
projects as a good hitter, and has shown lots of grit in his minor league
career so far. Consequently, we see him rising through and having a
tremendous 2005 season as he proves to everyone his true desire to reach the
25. Jason Arnold -RHP: Arnold's swift progression through the minors was stunted a little upon
his arrival at AAA. Arnold does not have an out pitch, as his fastball only
reaches 89-90 mph, and his control is suspect. The right-hander has some
refining to do, but has shown dominance when he is on. What Arnold needs to
learn is that you can't make it to the major leagues just on stuff, as you
must work hard constantly to reach the highest level of baseball. Arnold has
begun to realize that, and his success in the majors could depend on how
badly he wants to work at getting there.
26. Eric Crozier -1B: Crozier's all-out style of defense is exciting but his feast or famine
hitting leaves a lot to be desired. Hitting homers or striking out is no way
to secure an everyday major-league job, but his glove might prove useful off
27. Jordan De Jong -RHP: Another young pitcher who keeps hurting himself with the free passes, De
Jong has the ability to strike batters out consistently, and by not allowing
too many hits he is able to minimize any damage, which is evident by his low
ERA. De Jong will be twenty-six next season, and we are a little worried
that he has yet to master his control issues. The last thing the Jays need
is a reliever to come into the game and the first batter he faces to reach
base via the walk, and unlike the minor leagues, walking a player in the
majors will hurt you. If De Jong can master his control, he could be an
effective major league arm, however, if he fails to do so, he will remain an
28. Ryan Klosterman -SS: Klosterman could use his speed to advance through the minors as the Jays do
not have too many pure speed guys in the organization. Klosterman projects
to be a solid defensive shortstop, and a nice threat on the offensive end of
things. He is doing everything up to par right now, and belongs in the
middle of this ranking.
29. David Romero -LHP: Romero is a young lefty in the Jays system. His numbers for Charleston were
solid across the board. His 108 strikeouts in 103 innings is the stat the
jumps out at you the most, and by combining that with his seventy-seven hits
and 2.53 ERA, Romero is showing results on the mound. Many of his critics
will focus on his small stature as a reason why he will not succeed.
Standing at 5'10 and nearly 150 pounds, Romero projects to be more of a
reliever than a starter. If Romero can maintain his numbers at the Florida
State League he could be looked at with more respect, however, for now he
must be a max-effort guy at every level he plays.
30. Bubbie Buzachero -RHP: Aside from the great name, Buzachero became a lights-out relief pitcher for
the Jays high-A team last season. His K/9 IP is almost 9.00, and he
projects to have a solid chance for a future in a major league bullpen.
31. Tracy Thorpe -RHP: Injuries have set Thorpe back some, but not as much as walks have. Besides
his command, Thorpe's numbers are solid across the board. If Thorpe can
stay healthy and tone down the walks considerably, he could have a very
32. D.J. Hanson -RHP: Injuries have been the biggest enemy to Hanson's career so far. He missed
all of 2001 and also found himself on the sidelines for 2004. Hanson might
have already had an audition in the majors if not for the injuries. His
fastball is major-league ready and his two secondary pitches are solid as
well. If Hanson can remain healthy, look for him to turn some heads in
33. Miguel Negron -OF: Negron has been a disappointment since being drafted, but the talent is
still there if he can put it all together. His numbers, frankly, are not
very good, as his .269/.341/.411 line suggests. He has ability much along
the same lines as Alexis Rios, but has not been able to display it with any
consistency at any level so far.
34. Ron Davenport -OF: Davenport put up solid numbers last season at high-A as a twenty-year-old.
He is a typical outfielder who does not walk or strikeout much, and his
power should develop more as he advances. The upcoming season will be a big
one for Davenport as we will find out if his 2004 numbers were based on the
fact that he repeated Dunedin for the third straight season or whether he
really has turned into a solid player. He could either be in the top 20 next
year at this time or below the top 40.
35. Brian Hall -2B: A .879 OPS should get you mentioned in a top prospects list. Hall is an
above-average defensive second baseman whose bat at a middle infield
position is looking quite sound. In his first year in the minors last year
he struck out forty-nine times in 210 at bats, and is something he must
improve upon, but he is looking like he might have a bright future ahead.
36. Felix Romero -RHP: Romero had an outstanding 2004 season while splitting time between
Charleston and Dunedin. If he was a little younger, he would most definitely
be higher on the list, however, the right-hander has done everything
expected of him thus far. He could be moved up rapidly in 2005, and it will
not be a major surprise if he finishes the season at Syracuse.
37. Brian Reed -RHP: Reed, like Romero, split time between Charleston and Dunedin, but gave up
his share of hits during his stint in the Florida State League, and based on
his age we would like to see him be a little more dominant. He should begin
2005 with New Hampshire.
38. Danny Hill -RHP: The Jays' third round pick in 2004, Hill has quite a bit of talent, and
flourished last year in a relief role. His microscopic ERA and WHIP showed
that he can handle that level and that he can develop into a quality
reliever with closer potential.
39. Justin Maureau- LHP: Maureau was a pleasant surprise after he dominated the low-A league after being drafted in the third round of the 2002 draft. He had a disappointing 2003, and after starting 2004 on the disabled list he was sent to Dunedin in mid-season and struggled once again before finishing the season with Auburn. As a result of being a left-hander, and featuring an above-average breaking ball, we still feel Maureau has some potential in his arm, despite being twenty-four years old.
40. Carlo Cota -2B: One of few natural second basemen in the Jays system, Cota has improved
substantially over the years. Cota is beginning to develop some power, and
with his solid strike zone judgment could be a steal, drafted as he was in
the thirty-third round.
41. Danny Core -RHP: The Jays have an abundance of pitching prospects, and Core usually does not
get mentioned in the same breath as McGowan, Ramirez and Rosario. His
numbers do warrant some attention though. The competitive Core has become a
workhorse in the minors, and his 3.43 ERA, 1.21 WHIP and 7.6 K/9 IP might
get him more attention if he can keep it up.
42. Chi-Hung Cheng -LHP: Cheng has a successful 2004 season with Auburn, and some might wonder why
the young reliever is not ranked higher. The reason for this is that Cheng
was not very successful in locating the ball over the plate, and command is
a major issue that we look for in pitchers.
43. Michael MacDonald -RHP: MacDonald could turn out to be the steal of the draft, having turned in a
fabulous season after being selected in the 15th round of the 2004 draft.
The right-hander made an appearance as high as Charleston and figures to be
in the Dunedin rotation come 2005.
44. Christian Snavely -OF: The twenty-two year old outfielder has lots of tools in him, however, his
major weakness is the inability to make contact on a regular basis. Snavely
had an extraordinarily high strikeout ratio in 2004, and it could get worse
as he faces more mature and polished pitchers at the higher levels.
Nevertheless, he gets the benefit of the doubt for now.
45. Jason Alfaro -SS: Alfaro was signed to a minor league contract by the Blue Jays with an invitation to spring training on November 11, 2004. Alfaro is a protective hitter at the plate, as he will not draw many walks, but also will not strike out at a high ratio. When he is at the plate, you should expect contact to be made, which is why we view him as a solid role player for the Blue Jays.
46. Kurt Isenberg -LHP: Isenberg is one of the few lefties in the Jays system. He does not have the
dominant stuff of Purcey or Jackson, but he does possess some quality
pitches and good command. His delivery is smooth and he has a competitive
flair to him when he is on the mound.
47. Justin James -RHP: This right-hander could be the pitching version of Russ Adams. James is a
competitor and an intelligent pitcher, which compensates for his lack of
power. His curveball is looking like it might become his most dominant
48. Cameron Reimers -RHP: Reimer will soon be at the age where he will no longer be considered a
prospect. Reimers is a pure control pitcher who still needs to develop more
control. At this stage of the game it just might not happen. Has shown an
ability to log heavy inning totals, though.
49. Ryan Roberts -2B: Another second baseman to crack the top 50 is Ryan Roberts, only Roberts
is a converted third baseman. In high-A last year Roberts looked
overmatched, but his .350 OBP might prove better days are ahead as he learns
to control the strike zone even more. He has power and an ability to
exploit the outfield gaps.
50. Joey Metropoulos- 1B/OF: Metropoulos is another player of the draft class of 2004 to make this list. Metropoulos is a young first baseman that has the potential to flourish into a legitimate power corner infielder in the major leagues. Metropoulos will likely begin the 2005 season at Single-A with the Lansing Lugnuts, and will need to battle to prove he deserves playing time and an everyday job. There is too much power to ignore Metropoulos and he must be given the opportunity to play on an every day basis.
Top 50 Jays Prospects
Future Jays Top Stories
Blue Jays Place Jose Bautista on 15-Day DLJose Bautista has been placed on the 15-Day DL after suffering a left big toe injury resulting from an outfield collision with the wall
Ranking the 2016 MLB Draft: AL EastScout MLB Draft Expert Jeff Ellis reviews the 2016 MLB Draft by division. First up: the American League East.
2016 MLB Draft: Best available, day 2Who are the best players still available at the start of day 2 of the draft? Scout MLB Draft Expert Jeff Ellis fills us in.
2016 MLB Draft In Review: Round 2Scout's 2016 MLB Draft Expert Jeff Ellis breaks down the picks in the second round.