How Lefty-Heavy Might the 2015 Cardinals Be?

A look back at two decades of St. Louis Cardinals opening rosters with the focus on left-handed and switch-hitters.

One item discussed this spring by me and others is the heavy skew of the St. Louis Cardinals’ starting lineup toward left-handed hitters - while the projected bench could be entirely right-handed swingers.

Among the projected members of the starting eight, only Matt Holliday, Yadier Molina and Jhonny Peralta bat from the right side, with Matt Adams, Kolten Wong, Matt Carpenter, Jon Jay and newcomer Jason Heyward all lefty swingers.

Only once in the last 17 years, going back to Tony La Russa’s third year as Cardinals manager in 1998, did the club open the season with even four left-handed hitters in the regular lineup, let alone five, as we could see in 2015.

When we include switch-hitters along with full-time lefties, however, a starting total of four would not be unusual at all. That was achieved six times in the last 20 years, including as recently as 2013. Yet, 2015 would be the first time during this period with five left/switch-hitting starters to open the season.

At first blush, that would seem to suggest that the current roster construction might be out of balance. In terms of the starting lineup alone, it is definitely at the extreme; however in the larger context when including the bench, this would be a very typical population.

Taking the starters plus the reserves, the projected 2015 overall roster construction of five left/switch hitters on the 25-man opening day roster would be right on the team’s 20-year average. Yet, there has never been an entire right-handed bench since at least 1996.

In conclusion, the overall population of 13 hitters, split eight and five righty-lefty, could give Mike Matheny enough material with which to work. The challenge will be on the manager to determine how to deploy them most effectively in his daily lineups and to have the right bullets remaining for key late-game situations.

St. Louis Cardinals, left-handed and switch-hitters, opening roster, 1996-2015 (projected)

LH/SH Strs Bch Tot Starters        
2015* 5 0 5 Jay Adams Carpenter Wong Heyward
2014 3 2 5 Adams Carpenter Wong  
2013 4 1 5 Jay Descalso Carpenter Beltran(S)  
2012 4 2 6 Jay Descalso Furcal(S) Beltran(S)  
2011 2 2 4 Rasmus Schumaker      
2010 2 1 3 Rasmus Schumaker      
2009 3 2 5 Duncan Schumaker Ankiel    
2008 4 1 5 Duncan Schumaker Ankiel Izturis(S)  
2007 3 2 5 Duncan Edmonds Spiezio(S)    
2006 2 3 5 Miles(S) Edmonds      
2005 2 3 5 Walker Edmonds      
2004 3 3 6 Womack Edmonds Lankford    
2003 3 2 5 Vina Edmonds Martinez    
2002 4 1 5 Vina Edmonds Drew Martinez  
2001 3 3 6 Vina Edmonds Drew    
2000 3 2 5 Vina Edmonds Lankford    
1999 1 2 3 Drew        
1998 3 3 6 Lampkin Lankford DeShields    
1997 4 2 6 Lampkin Mabry DeShields McGee(S)  
1996 4 2 6 Alicea(S) Mabry Lankford McGee(S)  
Avg 3.1 2.0 5.1          
* proj       (S)witch        

Join the Spring Training discussion with other Cardinals fans here

Not yet a member of The Cardinal Nation? Join today for as little as $7.95 after our seven-day free trial and be able to read all of our exclusive content year-round.

Brian Walton can be reached via email at Also catch his Cardinals commentary daily at The Cardinal Nation blog. Follow Brian on Twitter.

© 2015 The Cardinal Nation, and All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

The Cardinal Nation Top Stories