Ted Simmons (Jasen Vinlove / USA TODAY Sports Images)

Since 1965, only two MLB clubs have had greater success from drafted players than the St. Louis Cardinals.

Though the St. Louis Cardinals will not have a first-round pick in 2017, they have done very well in the draft over time.

Editor’s note

With Friday’s signing of free agent center fielder Dexter Fowler, the St. Louis Cardinals forfeited their first-round selection in the 2017 First-Year Player Draft. It will be the first time the club will not make a pick in the initial round in a decade and a half. Back in 2002, St. Louis lost its first pick for signing free agent closer Jason Isringhausen.

Despite the Cardinals’ on-field success consistently placing them among those picking in the later part of each round of the drafts in recent history, the team has still been highly successful in finding valuable players throughout the drafts and developing them into major leaguers. By the way, drafts were once were 50 rounds long, but in 2012 were reduced to 40.

Though various round groupings are highlighted below, in the overall view, the Cardinals are third in most WAR earned from those drafted players who accrued at least 10 WAR each over the last 52 years.

If the past is any indication, the Cardinals should continue to prosper through the draft. Though as you will see quantified at the very end of this article, well over a third of the wins over replacement (or WAR) value over time across MLB has come from first-rounders.

A member of The Cardinal Nation’s message board community, SoonerinNC has taken on an exhaustive review of the MLB results of every player taken by every team in the draft back to its inception in 1965. A summary of his findings follow. – Brian Walton


By SoonerinNC

The study summarized below covers each major league team's performance in the 52 June regular drafts. As a cutoff, I listed each player with a career WAR of 10.0 or more according to Baseball Reference. Some Cardinals making that cut are Brendan Ryan, John Jay, Lance Lynn, Todd Worrell and Vince Coleman. Included were only players drafted and signed by the drafting team.

One conclusion is that the Cardinals had strong scouting but avoided the high dollar players in the early rounds. The current slotting system seems to have changed that, however, as the Cardinals are now spending more than their slot allowance and much more than in earlier years.

St. Louis had selections among the top 10 overall picks 10 times. Two of them did not make the majors and only four (J.D. Drew, Dimitri Young, Andy Van Slyke and Terry Kennedy) exceeded a career WAR of 10.0. Picking Pete Kozma with 2016 Cy Young Award winner Rick Porcello still on the board in 2007 is a good example.

The Cardinals’ success was more about quantity than Hall of Fame quality. Ted Simmons at 50.1 WAR is the top Cardinal drafted in the first five rounds. Only the top player from three recent MLB team additions (Rays, Marlins and Diamondbacks) has a lower WAR than Simmons.

The Cardinals lived up to their reputation as making good late round choices as they had the highest total WAR (324.1) and fifth-highest number of players making the list from rounds 11 or higher. Half of the WAR came from two players, Albert Pujols and Keith Hernandez.

The Cardinals were tied for third in number of first round players (24) but 13th with 353.0 WAR. In the 52 drafts, the Cardinals were among those with the top 10 overall picks 10 times, with their top choice Braden Looper at #3 in 1996. Only the Yankees and Red Sox, also very successful franchses, had fewer top 10 picks with seven each. The Yankees drafted Ron Blomberg at #1 overall in 1967.

Over the 52 years, the Brewers led the first round with a total WAR of 429.0. The Red Sox were tops over the first five rounds at 894.9. They also led rounds 6-10 with 269.5 and overall with 1321.4 WAR. The Cardinals’ overall total was 1048.4, good for third place. The Cardinals’ total of 39 players with a career WAR of 10.0 or more was second only to the Rangers with 40.

It is important to note that we are not comparing apples to apples, as the initial draft consisted of 20 of the current major league teams with four others joining in 1969. The Blue Jays and Mariners have the best performance of the post-1969 added teams. Overall the White Sox, Padres and Giants had the poorest performance of the early 24 teams. The Yankees also had less than average success.

The top three teams, the bottom ones and the Cardinals’ total WAR for the First Round, Rounds 1-5, Rounds 6-10 and 11 and higher are listed below. The original 20 teams make up each population and the top players in each team’s total are listed alongside.

  Round 1 WAR Top players      
1 Brewers 492 Braun Sheffield Molitor Yount
2 Mariners 434.3 Griffey ARod Tino Martinez  
3 Athletics 427.1 McGwire Chavez Chet Lemon Reggie Jackson
6 Cardinals  353 Simmons Drew Van Slyke  
19 Yankees 201.7        
20 Reds 191.6        
  Round 1-5          
1 Red Sox 894.9 Clemens Bagwell Dwight Evans  
2 Nationals/Expos  790.8 Randy Johnson Carter Raines  
3 Athletics 771.3 Henderson Jason Giambi Vida Blue  
13 Cardinals 574.7 Haren Reuss Yadier Molina  
20 Dodgers 397.4        
  Round 6-10          
1 Red Sox 269.9 Boggs Cecil Cooper Brady Anderson  
2 Angels 239.2 Edmonds Devon White    
3 Dodgers 236.1 Charlie Hough Doyle Alexander Bill Russell  
6 Cardinals 149.6 Lance Johnson Coco Crisp Terry Pendleton  
20 White Sox 42        
  Round 11+          
1 Cardinals 324.1 Pujols Keith Hernandez Polanco  
2 Rangers 307.4 Kinsler Kenny Rogers Mike Hargrove  
3 Dodgers 297.2 Piazza Hershiser Russell Martin  
20 Angels 74.4        
1 Red Sox 1321        
2 Athletics 1123        
3 Cardinals 1048        
20 Giants 661.8        

Final note – the first round does matter

Total WAR for all the qualifying players was 23,718.0. Of that, 15,156.5 or 63.9% was accrued by players drafted in the first five rounds, including 8,444.9 or 35.6% in the first round alone.

Bonus for members of The Cardinal Nation: Cardinals Lose Cordoba in 2016 Rule 5 Draft

Not yet a member?

Join The Cardinal Nation for the most comprehensive coverage of the St. Louis Cardinals from the majors through the entire minor league system. Take advantage of our seven-day free trial and a one-year subscription to Sports Illustrated now included with all new annual memberships.

© 2016 The Cardinal Nation, thecardinalnation.com and scout.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

The Cardinal Nation Top Stories