Auditing our Cards NLDS Roster Predictions

Mitchell Boggs is in. Todd Wellemeyer and Brad Thompson are out. How did Brian Walton do on his other post-season roster predictions?

Late last month, I posted my predictions for the St. Louis Cardinals initial post-season roster for the benefit of subscribers. Once the real answers are known, I like to loop back around to compare and discuss any differences.

The process I followed was to start with the 32 players then with the club and assess the chances of each. I went through the locks, those I thought would make the NLDS roster and those I thought would fall short.

Earlier, I had also shared with subscribers the Cardinals post-season roster history under Tony La Russa. In the last three playoffs, the club had gone with 11 pitchers and 14 position players. Early quotes from the general manager this fall were consistent with that.

Yet as the late season struggles of the club came into focus, a change in thinking occurred. Perhaps it was the desire to provide more relief help or the fact that there were no injured players to allow David Freese to be activated.

Whatever the reason, the Cardinals decided to go with 12 pitchers in the first round. They can still change that mix in subsequent rounds, however.

The pitcher on the bubble seemed to be Mitchell Boggs, who was told he made the roster on Monday at the expense of veterans Brad Thompson and Todd Wellemeyer, reports the St. Louis Post-Dispatch.

My other 24 predictions were accurate. My only miss was that I had assumed an 11/14 pitcher/position player mix with Freese in and Boggs out.

Following are the current details.

Starters (5) Relief (7) Catcher (2) Infield (7) Outfield (4)
starters Carpenter Molina Pujols Holliday
(8+3) Wainwright Schumaker Rasmus
Pineiro Ryan Ludwick
active Lohse Franklin LaRue Glaus Ankiel
non-start Smoltz Reyes Lugo
(14) Miller Thurston
taxi squad Wellemeyer Pagnozzi T Greene
(5) Thompson Freese
sent home Kinney K Greene

The eight starting position players and the starting pitchers for NLDS games one, two and three are listed on top, followed by the remainder of the 25-man active roster. At this point, the game four starter is not announced. It could be Kyle Lohse, John Smoltz or in an elimination game, even Chris Carpenter on short rest is an option.

Below the 25 are the other seven that were in the mix. We know Khalil Greene and Josh Kinney did not travel with the team to Los Angeles, leaving a five-man taxi squad.

The reason for this is that in recent years, MLB modified their post-season roster rules to allow in-series substitution of an injured player by another in the same position grouping (pitcher or position player). This way, the Cardinals have reserves immediately available if needed in an emergency.

One final point. As I detailed in an earlier subscriber article, the Cardinals past NLDS history under La Russa indicates that on the average, 22 players appear on the field, leaving three on the bench throughout the entire series.

In other words, the horses that brought the Cardinals to a 91-win regular season are the ones that need to step up again in the NLDS.

Not a subscriber? Join The Cardinal Nation now via our seven-day free trial and see what you have been missing!

Brian Walton can be reached via email at Also catch his Cardinals commentary daily at The Cardinal Nation blog.

© 2009 All rights reserved. This material may not be broadcast, published, rewritten or redistributed.

The Cardinal Nation Top Stories