Brad Rempel, USA Today

Doctor's Take: Cody Anderson to undergo Tommy John surgery

After being on indefinite shut down following a UCL sprain, Cody Anderson is now to undergo reconstruction surgery, officially ending the right handed pitcher's 2017 season. IBI injury expert Brandon Bowers gives us the medical details and an outlook on Anderson's future recovery.

On Sunday, March 19th it was announced that the 2017 season for Indians’ right handed pitcher Cody Anderson ended before it really even started. Anderson had been dealing with elbow soreness as of late, following a diagnosis of a mild ulnar collateral ligament sprain on March 10th. The 26-year-old received a second opinion from Dr. Keith Meister, who confirmed the diagnosis, and has elected to undergo an ulnar collateral ligament reconstruction at this time. Anderson was working his way back from surgery he had in November of last year to address posterior elbow impingement when his most recent elbow injury occurred.  

What is it? The ulnar collateral ligament (UCL) is located on the medial side of the elbow and serves to help stabilize the elbow while pitching, throwing etc. When standing upright, with the palms facing forward, medial refers to the side of the elbow closest to the body. The UCL connects the humerus (upper arm bone) to the ulna (one of the two long bones in the forearm). In overhead athletes, such as baseball players, the UCL is subject to high amounts of repeated force and therefore can be very vulnerable to injury. The term “sprain” refers to the over stretching or tearing of a ligament, in this case the UCL. Sprains are graded on a scale from one to three, with a grade one sprain being the least severe and representing a slight overstretch of a ligament and a grade three sprain being the most severe and represents a complete tear of the ligament. Grade one sprains are classified as mild, grade two sprains moderate and grade three sprains severe. With regards to the flexor strain, the term “strain” refers to the over stretching of a muscle, in this case a muscle in the forearm. The muscles in the forearm termed “flexors” are located on the palm side of the forearm.  

How is it fixed? The severity of an injury to the ulnar collateral ligament will usually dictate the treatment method utilized, with more conservative management utilized for less severe sprains and surgical management for more severe sprains. Conservative management consists of a period of rest/being shut down from baseball activities; time off allows the medial elbow to rest from the stresses incurred while throwing repeatedly. When more severe ulnar collateral ligament injuries occur, most often, surgical intervention is indicated. The surgery performed to repair a torn UCL is termed an ulnar collateral ligament reconstruction or Tommy John surgery. The surgery works to re-stabilize the medial elbow by reconstructing the UCL. The goal is to restore normal anatomy of the elbow, in an effort to allow the patient to return to their prior level of function. The new ulnar collateral ligament is formed from the tendon of the palmaris longus muscle, which is located in the forearm. An additional incision is made in order to surgically remove the palmaris longus muscle and harvest its tendon to utilize as the new ulnar collateral ligament. Following surgery, a long road of rehabilitation begins, that can last upwards of one year in length. Following surgery, a period of bracing will be used to allow time for healing of the reconstructed UCL to occur; the length of bracing will vary based on the surgeon’s protocol but can be anywhere from 6-8 weeks. During rehab, efforts to restore, full, pain free range of motion and strength of the elbow and affected arm are made with an eventual goal of reintroduction of dynamic activities. Specific progression through a UCL reconstruction postoperative protocol is based on a patient’s ability to meet all goals of one phase of the protocol before being allowed to advance to the next. The ultimate return to throwing/baseball decision is made by the patient’s surgeon.

My take.  Anderson’s 2017 season is over. Although the California native will be unable to impact the Tribe directly this season, his absence will pave the way for other pitchers in the organization to potentially contribute for the Tribe at the big league level.   

We will continue to monitor the status of Cody Anderson as he progresses through the rehab process and will provide the most up to date injury breakdown and analysis as new information becomes available.  

Brandon Bowers, PT, DPT, is a graduate of the University of Toledo, Doctor of Physical Therapy Program and currently practices in Columbus, Ohio.  He is an avid Cleveland sports fan and has experience rehabbing athletes of all levels and from a variety of sports.  Follow Brandon on Twitter for more Cleveland Indians injury insight and analysis:  @blbowers12

The information provided is the professional opinion of Brandon Bowers, PT, DPT and is based on his clinical experience and the most current clinical evidence available.  This information should not be interpreted as or substituted for medical advice for a specific condition or diagnosis.

Scout MLB Network Top Stories