Ken Blaze/USA TODAY Sports

Behind the Box Score: Solving Lance McCullers Jr.

The Cleveland Indians were prepared for the multitude of knuckle-curve pitches delivered by Lance McCullers Jr. as they laced seven hits to charge the budding superstar with five runs. The IBI's John Alfes takes you behind the box score to get a deeper look into why the Tribe was so successful on Wednesday evening...

CLEVELAND – A pivotal first inning proved to be the difference for the Cleveland Indians offense.

Facing Lance McCullers Jr., one of the better strikeout pitchers in the MLB with 11.63 K/9 entering play, the Tribe was able to take advantage of four location mistakes in the first inning, all of which were knuckle-curves out over the middle of the plate…

Carlos Santana (2-1 count, knuckle-curve pitch) 


Result: Leadoff single to center field

Distance: 268 feet

Pitch Velocity: 83.7-mph

Exit Velocity: 92.3-mph

Michael Brantley (0-2 count, knuckle-curve pitch)

Result: RBI double (barreled ball) to center field

Distance: 381 feet

Pitch Velocity: 85.2-mph

Exit Velocity: 100.1-mph

Edwin Encarnacion (1-1 count, knuckle-curve pitch)

Result: Sacrifice fly to right field

Distance: 319 feet

Pitch-Velocity: 86.7-mph

Exit Velocity: 92.1-mph

Jason Kipnis (1-2 count, knuckle-curve pitch)

Result: Single to left field

Distance: 150 feet

Pitch Velocity: 84.8-mph

Exit Velocity: 55-mph

The outburst did not expand beyond three runs as Lonnie Chisenhall grounded into a 4-6-3 double play to retire the side, but the home nine was able to claim an early 3-0 advantage, a nice cushion for Trevor Bauer and the pitching staff.

"He really went to that breaking ball. It’s a good one. It’s one of the better ones," said manager Terry Francona of McCuller's arsenal of pitches. "I don’t know about waiting on it. I think you’re trying to get in a hitter’s count and get a good pitch to hit.”

After McCullers settled in to retire nine of the next 11 hitters he faced between the second and fifth innings, he surrendered an additional two runs on knuckle-curves up in the zone to Francisco Lindor (double) and Brantley (two-run single) in the fifth frame.

"It's an approach that you want to take," Brantley said of hitting the off-speed the other way. "I mean, he has a very good breaking ball, like you said. Its a plus breaking ball, its one of the best breaking balls you're going to see all year. You're just trying to stay on it. You can roll them over with the best of them, especially when they are that good, so if you can stay on it and try to drive it the other way, you're going to have better success."

Francisco Lindor (0-1 count, knuckle-curve pitch)

Result: Double to left field

Distance: 22 feet

Pitch Velocity: 86-mph

Exit Velocity: 102.9-mph

Michael Brantley (2-1 count, knuckle-curve pitch)

Result: Two-run single to left field

Distance: 64 feet

Pitch Velocity: 87-mph

Exit Velocity: 101.9-mph

McCullers throws the knuckle-curve more than any other pitch as shown by his career-high 54.5% usage rate through his previous 24 innings (four starts) in 2017. In addition, the pitch is registering an average of 85.5-mph, 0.8-mph above his career average of 84.7-mph.

Analytics aside, the damage had been dealt to McCullers – 5 IP, 7 H, 5 R/ER, 3 BB, 5 K – an insurmountable lead that would last for three hours and 10 minutes of the contest.

John Alfes has covered the Indians for IBI since August of 2016. Follow him on Twitter @JohnAlfes for breaking news and in-depth coverage all season long.


Indians Baseball Insider Top Stories