Trans Blog: Collins, Holaday to Toledo

The Tigers made eight cuts on Monday morning, including ending two spring roster spot competitions, deciding on the final utility roles for the bench and the backup catcher job.

March 30 9:00 AM
  • HOLADAY, COLLINS TO Toledo

Optioned Tyler Collins (OF) and Bryan Holaday (C ) to Toledo

Reassigned Manny Pina (C ), Aaron Westlake (1B), Jordan Lennerton (1B), Jefry Marte (3B), Xavier Avery (OF), Jason Krizan (OF) to minor league camp

Analysis:

It was a big cut day on Monday morning in Lakeland, as the Tigers sent eight players across the road to minor league camp. The six reassignments were all expected given the optimistic outlook on Miguel Cabrera and Victor Martinez, meanwhile the two options likely bring to an end any competition for a position player spot.

Collins had a solid spring for the Tigers, showing the left-handed power that he was expected to have, while showing all of the other desirable character traits for a part-time/bench player. Unfortunately for Collins, the skill-set he has just doesn’t mesh well with what the Tigers need for their bench - preferring speed and defense to pop. Given there are already four outfielders that will need to split time among the three spots, Collins would have likely received minimal playing time, so a role in Toledo is probably more beneficial anyway.

Holaday entered camp as the incumbent backup catcher, but was likely facing an uphill battle from day one, as the organization was ready to give James McCann a longer look behind the plate. McCann also projects to complement Alex Avila much better, with more pop and offensive output from the right side of the plate. Holaday will remain valuable to the club as the most-days catcher in Toledo, and will likely need to be summoned at some point this season given Avila’s injury history. But for now, the backup catcher job is McCann’s.

Big league camp is now down to 29 players, with only the final few relief spots left to be determined, barring a trade of some sort.


March 28 5:00 PM
  • PUTKONEN HIGHLIGHTS MILB RELEASES

Released Luke Putkonen (RHP), Tanner Bailey (RHP), Jacob Butler (RHP), Tyler Gibson (OF), Charlie Gillies (RHP), Alex Lakatos (RHP), and Daryl Norris (RHP)

Analysis:

About a week after the minor league games begin do we get the first wave of releases, and this year is no different, as the Tigers announced seven cuts this morning. The list was highlighted by Putkonen, who pitched in parts of three seasons with the big league club. He had a successful 2013 season with a 3.03 ERA and an 8.5 K/9 rate in nearly 30 innings, but was derailed last year due to a bone spur in his elbow that required surgery. Observers said that Putkonen clearly wasn’t the same this spring.

Most of the others were not surprises, draft picks mostly from either last year or two years ago. The one player that did draw some surprise was Gibson, an athletic outfielder that has struggled to produce much and show consistent growth on the field, but still flashed the ability that enticed the Tigers to give him the bonus that they did out of the draft in 2011. His 2014 season didn’t get off to a bad start, as he hit .272 for West Michigan, but broke his hand, sidelining him for a couple months, and derailing the season.


March 26 10:00 AM
  • FARMER AND DOLIS HEAD TO TOLEDO

Optioned Buck Farmer (RHP) to Toledo

Assigned Rafael Dolis (RHP) to minor league camp

Analysis:

Two more cuts from big league camp, again, neither a surprise. While the Tigers wanted to give Farmer a look in relief this spring, most scouts still feel his future is in the rotation, and with only one full year of pro ball under his belt, he needs more time. Dolis has a live arm and turned some heads in camp, but wasn’t near the top of the pecking order for a roster spot. Big league camp is now down to 37 players.


March 24 3:00 PM
  • THINNING THE STAFF

Optioned Kyle Lobstein (LHP), Alex Wilson (RHP) and Josh Zeid (RHP) to Toledo

Assigned Alberto Cabrera (RHP) to minor league camp

Analysis:

More cuts from big league camp happened on Tuesday, as the Tigers sent out four pitchers, to bring the total number of players still in camp down to 39.

Neither Cabrera nor Lobstein were considered serious threats to make the team out of spring training, that despite Lobstein’s success down the stretch last summer, giving the Tigers six strong starts at a time when they were in desperate need for anyone to start a game and give them a chance to win a game. While Lobstein wasn’t in serious competition for a rotation spot with the five guys set prior to spring training beginning, he’s likely to be on the very short list should a need arise for a starter.

Wilson and Zeid were both added this off-season with the hope of being able to compete for a bullpen spot, however, with the return of Bruce Rondon and the resigning of Joba Chamberlain, right-handed relief roles were not plentiful. To add to it, both relievers struggled in their spring training appearances, with both posting an ERA over seven and walking more than they struck out. They will nevertheless be at the top of the list for when a bullpen need arises.


March 22 4:00 PM
  • SPRING SIGNINGS

Optioned Steven Moya (OF) to Toledo


March 20 10:00 AM
  • FIRST MLB CAMP CUTS

Assigned Omar Duran (LHP), Miguel Gonzalez (C ), Austin Green (C ), Joe Mantiply (LHP), Tim Melville (RHP) and Luke Putkonen (RHP), to minor league camp

Optioned Daniel Fields (OF), Dixon Machado (SS), Jose Valdez (RHP) and Drew VerHagen (RHP) to Triple-A Toledo

Optioned Wynton Bernard (OF) to Double-A Erie

Analysis:

The first round of cuts from big league camp are in, and there are no surprises yet, as is to be expected. Guys like VerHagen or Fields might have had a very outside shot at competing for a roster spot, but probably would have needed an injury or something along those lines to make it happen. The rest of the guys were destined for the minor leagues anyway, and just were getting the opportunity in big league camp.

Major League camp still has 44 players in it, so there will still be a number of additional cuts to get down to the final 25-man roster between now and when camp breaks just before Opening Day. Those decisions will likely involve quite a bit more competition and debate for the final roster spots.

As TigsTown has mentioned, there are only roughly five roster spots open at this point in time, with the other 20 spoken for. That means there are more or less 24 guys left in big league camp competing for one of five spots to start the year in Detroit.


March 18 12:00 PM
  • SPRING SIGNINGS

Signed Jiwan Jones (OF) to minor league deal

Signed Ryan Perry (RHP) to minor league deal

Signed Lance Durham (1B/DH) to minor league deal

Released Joel Hanrahan (RHP)

Jamie Johnson (OF) retired



Tigs Town Top Stories