Coming off a 2008 in which he registered 51 tackles, 8.5 sacks and three forced fumbles in 14 games for the Titans, Albert Haynesworth was in the conversation for Defensive Player of the Year.
His reward as the premier free agent on the market was a seven-year, $100 million contract from the Redskins that could max out at $115 million, with $41 million of it guaranteed, making him the richest defensive player in the history of the NFL. An immovable object along the interior at 6-6 and 350 pounds, Haynesworth features incredible athleticism and play-making ability for a man of his size. Not only was his presence alone going to make the Washington run defense a force to be reckoned with, but the pass rush would inevitably improve since the former Tennessee Volunteer commands double teams on most every snap.
However, the Redskins actually fell from No. 8 in the league defending the run in 2008 without Haynesworth to No. 16 in 2009 with him, and their opponent's yards-per-carry average curiously increased from 3.8 to 4.0. It did seem that having him in the middle had a positive effect on pass rushers Andre Carter and rookie Brian Orakpo, who recorded 11.0 sacks each, although Haynesworth himself wasn't nearly as productive. His numbers were down across the board and snapped his streak of two straight Pro Bowls: 37 tackles, 4.0 sacks and zero forced fumbles in 12 games.
Most importantly, Washington fell from 8-8 last season to 4-12 this season, and while a sputtering offense deserves the lion's share of the blame, the defense was no better than it was the year before – it even dropped, from No. 4 overall to No. 10.
The lesson here for the Bears, and for every other team with money to burn come Mar. 5, is that there are no guarantees in free agency.
According to Scout.com's rankings, here are the six five-star free agents that changed uniforms last offseason, not including the aforementioned Haynesworth:
QB Matt Cassel2008 Team: Patriots
2009 Team: Chiefs
Contract: six years, $63 million
Technically, Cassel was slapped with the franchise tag before being traded from New England to Kansas City for a second-round draft pick, but he was still considered the prize of the free-agent class under center since Kurt Warner wasn't going anywhere. Not only did Cassel's TD-to-INT ratio drop from 21-to-11 with the Patriots to 16-to-16 with the Chiefs, but his team's record dropped from 11-5 to 4-12.
2009 Team: Seahawks
Contract: five years, $40 million
Finally ready to be No. 1 after playing his entire career in Chad Ochocinco's shadow, Houshmandzadeh caught 79 passes for 911 yards and three touchdowns his first season in the Emerald City. While those are respectable numbers, especially with quarterback Matt Hasselbeck missing some time with injury, 15 players in the league had more receptions, 27 had more yards and 68 had more TDs.
2009 Team: Ravens
Contract: three years, $12 million
Coming off six Pro Bowl selections during an 11-year run in Minnesota, Birk made the move to Baltimore. The Ravens were fifth in the league running the ball at 137.5 yards per game and allowed signal caller Joe Flacco to be sacked a middle-of-the-road 36 times after Birk's arrival, although they were fourth in rushing at 148.5 yards per game and saw Flacco hit the deck just 33 times before Birk came to town.
2009 Team: Rams
Contract: five years, $37.5 million
St. Louis has been a terrible football team in recent years, although they did jump from 25th to 20th in rushing offense from 2008 to 2009. Much of the credit must go to running back Steven Jackson, who enjoyed a terrific season even though he was the only threat the Rams had all season long, but perhaps Brown did a commendable job coordinating the blocking in the trenches.
LB Bart Scott2008 Team: Ravens
2009 Team: Jets
Contract: five years, $40 million
Following former Ravens defensive coordinator and new Jets coach Rex Ryan from Baltimore to New York, Scott's numbers in green and white were nearly identical to what they were in purple and black. The Jets unexpectedly made it all the way to the AFC Championship Game, and although Scott wasn't as much of a playmaker on defense as cornerback Darrelle Revis, he was a quality addition.
2009 Team: Broncos
Contract: five years, $17 million
The heart and soul of what was seemingly always a dominant Philadelphia defense during his 13 years there, Dawkins was given a lot of credit for Denver flying out of the shoot 6-0 to start the 2009 campaign. But while Dawkins finished with a career-high 116 tackles and picked off two passes, the Broncos crumbled down the stretch and lost eight of their final 10 games to miss the playoffs yet again.
Conclusion: Contracts given to these seven players totaled $309.5 million during last year's free-agency period, but there were more misses than hits.
Birk and Scott were the only two that suited up in the playoffs this year. Haynesworth and Cassel went from winning teams to losing teams. Cassel, Houshmandzadeh, Brown and Dawkins would have been in the postseason had they just stayed where they were. The Rams were awful before signing Brown, and they remained awful after signing Brown. Birk and Scott are the only ones that enjoyed about the same amount of both individual and team success.
Maybe Bears general manager Jerry Angelo should consult this list before he talks himself into offering defensive end Julius Peppers a Haynesworth-like deal.
Agree? Disagree? Let your voice be heard on our message board RIGHT HERE.
John Crist is the Publisher of Bear Report and a member of the Professional Football Writers of America. To read him every day, visit BearReport.com and become a Chicago Bears insider.
Zero Guarantees in Free Agent Hunt
Bear Report Top Stories
Bear Report Podcast: Week 1 OTA ReviewJeremy Stoltz and Aaron Leming discuss the first week of Chicago Bears off-season training activities (OTAs), with updates on Mike Glennon, Mitch Trubisky, Kevin White, Jordan…
Bear ReportYesterday at 11:58 AM
Bears sign WR Victor CruzThe Chicago Bears have signed former New York Giants wide receiver Victor Cruz to a one-year contract.
Bear ReportThursday at 12:11 PM
Bears QB room a work in progressWith so many new faces at the most important position in football, the Chicago Bears quarterback room is in a state of flux, a problem that will be exacerbated if the team's brutal…
Bear ReportThursday at 10:55 AM
Bears 2017 OTA Notebook: Week 1We empty the notebook from the first practice of Chicago Bears off-season training activities (OTAs) open to the media, which was our first opportunity to see the entire 90-man…
Bear ReportTuesday at 11:54 AM
Chicago Bears 2017 OTAs PrimerWe break down the top Chicago Bears storylines heading into off-season training activities (OTAs), which will be conducted over the next three weeks.
Bear ReportMonday at 11:15 AM