Barry: Woo hoo!!
Barry: We have a quorum
Barry: ONE: Don Banks of SI today reported that Adrian Peterson
re-injured his collarbone and might be out 2-3 months. Do you think
that this is a further indictment of Peterson's fragility, and would it change
your stance on whether or not to draft the Oklahoma RB?
John: Not at all.
Rich: No. Don't believe it. Sounds like a smokescreen
to me by team that
wants to see him fall.
Rich: Adrian Peterson all the way.
Barry: Roger Goodell warned teams not to reveal interview info today,
John: Yeah, that'll happen.
Jeff: I have respect for Don Banks. He's not going to make stuff up.
Barry: So is everyone convinced that Peterson is just unlucky, not a
Barry: Fred you get tonight's succinct reply award :-)
John: Yeah, pretty much. Although, it does have to at least be a little
bit of a concern.
Rich: I still don't believe it. Did you notice
the run Peterson made in
the Fiesta Bowl in overtime?
Rich: Did it look like he had an injury then?
Jeff: He missed only one game before the collar bone. He can play with
John: I agree with Jeff, Rich. Banks is not the kind of writer who just
throws this stuff out there.
Barry: So no one jumps off the Peterson bandwagon.
John: Not I, Barry.
For the record it just ups my nervousness level from "kinda
twitchy" to "twitchy".
Of course it should be at least a
little bit of a concern. How could it not be?
Barry: QUESTION TWO
Barry: TWO: It's the second round, and the Browns have added a QB or
running back, and are now choosing between an OG or CB.
Assuming that the players are equally capable at their position, what's your
Rich: The guard
Fred: Highest rated player
Jeff: I want a cornerback.
Rich: There will be more highly rated guards there than cornerbacks.
John: If they are equally rated, CB
Fred: I do think the Browns have to get a starting CB in this draft
Barry: Jeff and John in lockstep, Rich wants his OG, Fred doesn't choose
based on position.
Rich: They also need another defensive lineman or two.
Hey! They re-signed Simon Fraser! What are you talking about?
Rich: I rest my case.
Barry: My take is that it's OG because the CB class is deeper.
Jeff: Sure, they need guards, but you want to start Daven Holly for 16
Fred: That's why I think the second rounder should be CB
John: I actually wouldn't mind that, Jeff. But they shouldn't look to not
upgrade the position because they have Holly.
Barry: Good point, Jeff, I'm just hoping they can get a CB in round
three. Probably too optimistic.
Jeff: I think Seth McKinney is a pretty good guard.
John: If he's healthy, he's better than Cosey.
Rich: I do, too. What's all the concern about him?
Barry: Big hole at CB, smaller one at OG.
Barry: McKinney's pretty solid, but maybe not the RG of the future.
Fred: He missed last season with neck injury
John: His neck and because of the fact that he missed '06 because of said
Barry: We done on this one?
Rich: Why not a DL?
Tank Tyler should be there
John: Yer the TV star. You decide.
Barry: I just read the cue cards.
Barry: QUESTION THREE!
Barry: The Chiefs are supposedly shopping Larry Johnson. Second and
fourth round picks for RB Larry Johnson. Yes or no?
Fred: I'd think about that
John: Wow, that's a shocking answer Rich.
Rich: I'm shocked, too.
Barry: Surprised... from the Peterson pimp and all!
John: I'm torn on this one. I'd probably lean toward Rich's line of
Fred: That's scary
Rich: What's it gonna take to knock you over?
Jeff: I agree with Rich on this one. Johnson is in the last year of his
contract and will want megabucks.
John: That made me nauseous to type, btw. :-)
Barry: Wow... I think some Browns fans would love to see him here, but
he would break the bank.
John: He wants to break two banks.
Rich: And from what I've read, he's not
exactly a positive guy in he
Fred: That would solve the RB spot and you could get the QB or Thomas
John: He's a cancer in the locker room.
Rich: yeah. that.
Barry: Philosophical question FOUR... prepare for deep thinking.
Rich: We're all in trouble.
John: Rich, you can pass on this one.
Barry: Brady Quinn's name keeps coming up with respect to the Browns.
Question. On balance, which way do you look at Quinn's
experience with the Fighting Irish and Charlie Weis - negatively, in that he
might not have more upside, or positively, in that he's more NFL
Barry: Ponder your stance, and reply when ready.
John: There's no way that anyone can convince me that Quinn's time with
Weis is anything but a positive.
Fred: I would say it
Rich: He's going to be a good NFL quarterback. I'm just no cerain he will
be a great NFL quarterback.
Fred: I would say it would be positive as he's played in a pro style
offense and was forced to carry the team
John: That's really not a deep question, Barry. I sense you are becoming
a prima donna before our very eyes.
Barry: Be quiet, Taylor, you not-on-TV guy, you.
Jeff: I go with upside. On some quarterbacks there is a lot of
projection. That's why there are so many flops.
Rich: not certain
John: How is it not a positive?
Fred: Don't upset him. we want him to call in Friday
Barry: Oh yeah. Sorry.
Rich: Quinn will always have more upside because of his exposure to Weis.
Barry: By "upside", I meant that what you see how with Quinn is all
you're gooing to get.
Barry: That's sorta of a negative.
Barry: Oh well, crappy question. I'll make it appear brilliant when I
John: Russell has a higher ceiling than Quinn. The biggest question is:
who's a better bet to reach their ceiling, Quinn or Russell?
Rich: Don't agree. He'll improve. The question is how much?
Barry: FIVE: Why do you think Browns fans are so enthusiastic towards
Adrian Peterson and Joe Thomas, and so wary of Brady
Fred: I think Russell has a higher ceiling
Rich: Tough question. One possible answer is neither.
Jeff: I asked Phil Savage that specific question. He says Quinn has a
lot of growing left.
Barry: Is it anti-Notre Dame, Tim Couch hangover, or a nostalgia for
great runners and OL lines of the past.
Fred: Because they want a gamebreaker running back or good offensive
line for once
John: Combo of all three, Barry.
Barry: Not so much anti-Quinn as pro-running attack, Fred?
Fred: Yes, run the ball and stop the run
John: A lot of ND hate in Brownstown.
Rich: As the risk of being repetitious: Great running backs make average
offensive lines look good and good offensive lines look great.
Not the other way around.
Barry: Bad passing attacks make both look bad.
Rich: Fred's right. Run it well and stop it well.
Jeff: Notre Dame hype, Tim Couch and watching LSU manhandle Quinn.
Funny, though, most fans around here want to dismiss what
Troy Smith did in the Florida game.
Rich: But they still can't make him 6-4.
John: Imagine that, Jeff. :-)
Barry: I don't. That scared me off of Troy Smith.
Barry: He looked like every Browns quarterback since 1999 in that game
because of the rush.
Rich: What scared me off was his height.
Barry: LIGHTNING ROUND... LIGHTNING ROUND... LIGHTNING ROUND... LIGHTNING ROUND...
Barry: 1. Your top -> realistic <- second round pick. Name 'em.
Rich: Tanard Jackson
John: Highest rated guard or corner.
Fred: Peterson-Sears-Daymian Hughes
John: Specific? Blalock or Eric Wright. Or Grubbs if he happens to fall.
Barry: Arron Sears in the second, Fred?
Fred: If he's there
Barry: Got someone you're hoping for in Round 2, Jeff?
Jeff: Trent Edwards
Barry: Oooo, interesting.
Jeff: I have Joe Thomas in the first round.
Rich: If they go Edwards in the second, they're nuts.
Barry: I give Fred a point for Arron Sears because he agrees with me.
John gets a half-point for his optimism.
John: Gotta agree with Rich.
John: Man I hate typing that.
Rich: Talk about reaching.
Rich: Then don't.
John: Calm down, gramps.
Barry: What?!? Why do you think he's a reach?
Barry: Do you think Beck would be a reach at 2?
Rich: Fist of all, they don't need a quarterback. But if they do take
one, the second round is way too early, especially with all the other
need positions on the board.
Barry: Alright. Difference of opinion shows up in the lightning round.
Barry: QUESTION TWO
Barry: On a scale from 1 to 10, with 1 meaning complete irrelevance and
10 indicating having a remote control which dictates what Phil
Savage says at all times, how much input does Romeo Crennel have on this year's
#1 draft pick.
John: "4.5". That's funny, Fred.
Rich: Anything more than zero would be too much.
John: What kept you from "4.6"?
Barry: Doesn't matter. Correct answer is one.
Rich: I was closer.
Fred: law of averages
Barry: QUESTION THREE
Barry: Same question, except substitute Randy Lerner.
Rich: Les than zero.
John: less than zero
John: damn you Passan
Rich: Damn you, too, Taylor.
John: I spelled it right the first time, so I get the credit.
Rich: Not in my book.
Barry: Wow. It's unanimous.
Rich: Didja expect anything different?
Barry: Yes, with so many folks saying Lerner is impacting the pick. I
don't agree with them either, but I'm surprised no one gives it any
John: "any" is being kind.
John: Less than zero is the correct answer.
Rich: Those who believe he is are ill informed.
Barry: QUESTION FOUR: Which pick by the Browns would SURPRISE you the
most: Peterson, Thomas, or Quinn
Barry: Interesting... I'm glad you've joined us Jeff.
John: Look at the new guy, being all different and stuff.
Rich: Be ready, Jeff.
Rich: So you gonna give his one to the newcomer, Barry?
Barry: QUESTION FIVE: The Lions signed WRs Marcus Robinson and Cliff Russell, bringing
their roster to 50% wide receivers. Do any of you believe for a
second that they would take Calvin Johnson?
Fred: No. only a trade set up
John: No way
Rich: And they're not gonna take Thomas. Don't be surprised if they
John: WTF does the signing of training camp fodder and washed-up
never-has-beens have to do with CJ?
Jeff: They might draft Johnson and then trade him.
Rich: Why not just trade?
Barry: It just seems like they've got enough WR for the entire NFC
North, John, that's all.
John: Nice one, Fred. :-)
Fred: If they can't get it done in 15 minutes
Jeff: Draft and trade worked for the Chargers
Barry: Gotta give Jeff a point there, except my reason for them picking
CJ was "Millen is a moron".
Rich: Matt Millen isn't that smart.
John: Just don't be surprised if/when the Lions take CJ and keep him.
John: How can anybody argue with anyone taking CJ?
Rich: That's if he Raiders don't grab him first.
Barry: Just one last thing before we go... do any of you think that the
Browns might walk off with Johnson on Saturday?
John: Highly, highly doubtful.
Rich: There's a chance, John?
Fred: It would be the re-invention of Millen unless they trade Braylon
for a first rounder
John: Don't think so, Rich.
John: But you just never know.
Barry: I think anyone who gives us a first-rounder for BE would be
Barry: Any chance of CJ in orange and brown, Jeff?
Jeff: I don't think so.
Death Chat: Pre-Draft Staredown
The OBR Top Stories
Buy One Month - Get the Summer on Us!Buy a monthly subscription to the OBR and get all our draft coverage - plus two free months tacked on for free! Already a monthly subscriber? Upgrade to an annual subscription and…
The OBR5:50 AM
Best Player Available Drafting Is a LieWe've talked Best Player Available Drafting, Need Drafting and Best Value Available Drafting. Why the first one is a lie.
The OBRYesterday at 5:49 PM
7 Round Browns NFL Mock DraftWe are almost there. The NFL Draft is this week so it is time for, likely, the last 7 Round Mock Draft for our Browns.
The OBRSunday at 4:36 PM
Does DeShone Kizer fit into Browns mix at QBDeShone Kizer is considered one of the top four quarterbacks in this year's NFL Draft, but his rankings are varied by draft experts
The OBRSunday at 2:30 PM