Coach Ken Whisenhunt's decision two weeks ago to start Max Hall drew rave reviews and sparked optimism from the team's fans.
But to Whisenhunt's credit, he has advised caution and warned of the perils of starting a rookie.
Whisenhunt would have preferred not to be a prophet, but that's what he looked like after the 22-10 loss to Seattle last Sunday.
Hall completed just 4 of 16 passes before being knocked out of the game in the third quarter.
Still, it's telling that Whisenhunt planned to stay with Hall if he had not been injured. And he plans to start him this week against Tampa Bay if Hall is sufficiently recovered from a second blow to the head in as many weeks.
"Let's be frank," Whisenhunt said. "You understand with a young quarterback in this type of environment (on the road), you're going to have to grow and learn with some of those things. And we understood that."
As has been his custom, Hall made mistakes early. This time, however, he never recovered.
His third pass was intercepted, and he was wild throughout the day. He missed Larry Fitzgerald for a touchdown, and he overthrew other open receivers.
It's hard to say if Whisenhunt's decision to stick with Hall says more about his belief in the rookie or his lack of confidence in backup Derek Anderson.
Anderson sparked the offense in the third quarter in Seattle, but he had four starts in which to prove himself. He barely completed 50 percent of his passes, and it's clear Whisenhunt knows what he's going to get out of the veteran.
The hope is that Hall will improve dramatically with more playing time. The problem is, he has taken some vicious blows.
In his first start, he tried to run and took a blow to the head. He returned from that one.
But he didn't recover from the hit last Sunday, and that could keep him from playing against Tampa Bay.
Because of his inexperience, Hall needs all the practice time he can get. It's doubtful Whisenhunt would feel comfortable starting the rookie unless he's able to practice fully on Wednesday or at minimum, Thursday and Friday.
If he can't, Anderson will start against the Bucs. The Cardinals have not gained more than 267 yards of offensive in any game this season and twice have been below 200.
Cards: Hall Roughed Up, Remains Starter
CardinalsSource Top Stories
McDonough still in play for San FranciscoAccording to reports, Arizona Cardinals' vice president of player personnel Terry McDonough is one of the final four candidates remaining in the San Francisco 49ers' search for a…
CardinalsSourceYesterday at 1:48 PM
2016 in review: J.J. NelsonSecond-year receiver J.J. Nelson enjoyed a breakout campaign for the Cardinals, as he finished the year with 34 receptions and 568 yards.
CardinalsSourceYesterday at 12:45 PM
Position capsule: Tight endThe Arizona Cardinals don't have a starting-caliber tight end under contract yet for 2017, but that could change quickly if the team elects to re-sign Jermaine Gresham.
CardinalsSourceYesterday at 11:19 AM
Play anatomy: David Johnson vs. SeattleIn this installment of our "Play Anatomy" series, CardinalsSource looks at David Johnson's 29-yard reception in week 16 against Seattle that help set up the Cardinals' game-winning…
CardinalsSourceYesterday at 10:44 AM
2016 in review: John BrownDespite being diagnosed with sickle-cell trait almost halfway through the season, Cardinals' wide receiver John Brown battled through pain and racked up over 500 receiving yards.
CardinalsSourceTuesday at 10:08 AM