Panthers 2014 Final Report Card: WRs

The Carolina Panthers wide receiver position was one of the biggest question marks entering this season. Last offseason, longtime Panther Steve Smith was let go and the Panthers drafted the heir apparent in Kelvin Benjamin. Here are the grades for the rookie wide receiver and the rest of the players at the position for this year.

Kelvin Benjamin

2014 Stats: 73 receptions, 146 targets, 1,008 receiving yards, 9 touchdowns

Best Game: Week 11 versus Atlanta

Worst Game: Week 9 versus New Orleans

Notes: The rookie out of Florida State was given a tall challenge being thrown in as a number one wide receiver right out of the gate. While he had his moments, both good and bad, it is safe to say that he certainly met that challenge and played at a high level in his first year in the NFL. The most impressive part about Benjamin’s performance his rookie year was that he did it without a real number two wide receiver. The likes of Jason Avant or Jerricho Cotchery never struck fear in opposing defenses and this allowed them to focus more on Benjamin but he still was able to put together solid numbers.

The one issue Benjamin had, and this dates back to his college days, is the dropped passes. Benjamin actually finished the year tied for the most dropped passes in the NFL with ten, according to Sporting Charts. If he can correct this he will be a matchup nightmare for opposing cornerbacks because of his size and speed.

Final Grade: A-


Jerricho Cotchery

2014 Stats: 48 receptions, 78 targets, 580 receiving yards, 1 touchdown

Best Game: Week 15 versus Tampa Bay

Worst Game: Week 10 at Philadelphia

Notes: The fact that the Panthers were relying so heavily on two rookies (Benjamin, Brown) and a second-year player (Bersin) they needed a player like Jerricho Cotchery. The 11-year veteran was almost the opposite of Benjamin in the fact that he was very sure-handed (had only one drop all year) and started to have a bigger role in the offense towards the end of the year because of this. The last three games of the regular season he caught every pass thrown his way, 13 in total, and had his only touchdown of the year in Week 15 against Tampa Bay.

The issue with Cotchery is he doesn’t have that breakaway speed and when he makes a catch is tackled almost immediately. He finished with one of his lowest yards per catch average in his career (12.1 yards per catch).

Final Grade: C+


Philly Brown

2014 Stats: 21 receptions, 36 targets, 296 yards, 2 touchdowns

Best Game: Week 3 versus Pittsburgh

Worst Game: Week 15 versus Tampa Bay

Notes: The undrafted rookie from Ohio State showed enough this year to warrant another look in training camp because of his game-changing speed. The thought would have been that after Jason Avant was released that Brown would see an increased amount of looks, which he did, but it didn’t result in receptions. Over the final seven games, Brown had four or more targets in five of those games, compared to only two in the first eight games. However his highest reception total over those final seven games was three, which happened twice. Brown certainly is talented enough to play the position in the NFL and has the speed that teams covet. The Panthers will need to find a way to be more effective with his targets though.

Final Grade: C


Brenton Bersin

2014 Stats: 13 receptions, 20 targets, 151 yards 1 touchdown

Best Game: Week 7 at Green Bay

Worst Game: Wild Card versus Arizona

Notes: Brenton Bersin did not see much time at the wide receiver position and aside from three games (at Cincinnati, at Green Bay, at Philadelphia) he didn’t receive more than one target in any game. Bersin primarily saw his playing time on special teams where he seemed to struggle at times securing the ball, like the Wild Card game against the Cardinals. It will be interesting to see what role Bersin has on the Panthers heading into next season.

Final Grade: D+


Panther Insider Top Stories