Why he should go: He hasn't made near the impact many expected -- including his ex-coaches with the Jets. Morton gets hurt too often, rarely makes big returns, and can be easily supplanted by others. Ladell Betts and James Thrash would do better on kick returns, offering more consistency. Antonio Brown, Santana Moss and R.W. McQuarters, if signed, would be better on punt returns. Morton probably would have been better as a third-down back, but his size worked against him.
Why he should stay: Because there's little incentive to release him before training camp. If one of the other players gets hurt, an experienced return man is on the roster.
Why he should go: Because he's old and coming off a year-long injury. There's no guarantee he'll be available. Plus he's way too expensive to keep around as an insurance policy. Also, the Redskins have worked all offseason to stock up at linebacker, from the draft and in free agency. There's a reason; they can't count on Barrow playing any longer. And Washington's coaches prize linebackers capable of playing all three spots; Barrow is limited to one.
Why he should stay: Because when healthy he's a better middle linebacker than anyone else on the roster. His instincts are those of a middle linebacker, something Lemar Marshall or Warrick Holdman can't say. That makes a big difference, possibly the difference between a sustained drive or a stop. Of course, the healthy part is now a key issue. Check that; it's a major issue.
Why he should go: Because he wants out and the Redskins don't want him. Sounds like enough of a reason for me. Gardner has never improved upon his second season, which was a good one. That season, he made excellent catches in traffic and used his body like a rebounder's in basketball. A change of scenery would do him well.
Why he should stay: Because he only has one year remaining on his contract. Washington's savings would have been the same in March as they would be in June. Also, as with Morton, if the Redskins keep him around in camp and another team suffers an injury at receiver, they could make a trade. That way they'd get something for him.
June 1: Will They Stay or Will They Go?
Breaking Burgundy Top Stories
Williams Returns; Redskins Injuries Run DeepBusy day at Redskins Park headlined by the return of Washington Pro Bowl tackle and a lengthy injury report.
Breaking BurgundyYesterday at 11:27 AM
Upon Further Review: The Manny Benton ShowThe Manny Benton Show gives a second-look review of the Redskins loss to the Arizona Cardinals.
Breaking BurgundyTuesday at 10:01 PM
The Redskins' Lucky Number Is 7This isn't about Joe Theismann, but the Redskins aiming for a second straight playoff birth.
Breaking BurgundyMonday at 10:47 PM
Snap Judgments: Redskins-CardinalsWashington has a new lead dog at safety, at least for one week.
Breaking BurgundyMonday at 7:12 AM
Morning Manny: Silverback Returns. Now what?With Trent Williams back in the fold, Manny Benton wonders if the Redskins missed his presence.
Breaking BurgundySunday at 6:57 PM