First, let's review what the Bears gave up for Jay Cutler and a 2009 5th round pick:
QB Kyle Orton
2009 1st round pick (18)
2009 3rd round pick (84)
2010 1st round pick (Currently will be between the 7th and 10th pick)
Now, let's have a look at the stats of both of those QB's:
Jay Cutler: 294/487, 60.7%, 3117 yards, 19 TD, 25 INT, 31 sacks, 71.1 Rating, 5-9 Record
Kyle Orton: 277/444, 62.4%, 3,182 yards, 17 TD, 8 INT, 24 sacks, 89.2 Rating, 8-6 Record
Now, let's have a look at the stats of the QB Cutler was being sought for the replacement of:
Jason Campbell: 260/398, 65.3%, 2,946 yards, 17 TD, 12 INT, 33 sacks, 89.0 Rating, 4-9 Record
Say what you want, but honestly, the Redskins have the better QB this season statistically speaking between him self and Jay Cutler. Add to that fact, Kyle Orton is only performing slightly better than Jason Campbell as well. All three teams have their share of the problems, but the Redskins clearly have the worst of it with the injuries to the Offensive Line, a Lame Duck Head Coach and a change at Play Caller mid-season.
I know many fans want a change at QB and it is understandable. While Jason Campbell has put up better stats than Jay Cutler, the fact is, he does not appear to be a winner in the fans' eyes. This is no surprise as Jason Campbell has not been a come back type of QB. In fact, stats show that he is at his best when the Redskins are winning or losing by a large margin. When the game is close, his stats dip substantially. Of course, a coach and talent scout will have to make the determination if that is only on the shoulders of Jason Campbell. A winner is what the Redskins need next season no matter who the coach is.
However, as bad as fans want a change at QB, it should also be noted that a change to Jay Cutler would not have been a good change. When you factor in the price the Bears paid for him, his performance this season, and his being compaired to Jeff George attitude wise, this trade would have been a huge mistake for the Redskins.
So it stands to reason that the refusal to offer more than the Bears might just be the best move Vinny Cerrato ever made, or didn't make, for the Washington Redskins.
As far as next season goes, this is where it gets interesting. If the rumors of Mike Shanahan to the Redskins come true and he is the next coach, would he then try to acquire Jay Cutler since he is familiar with him? One would think it is at least possible. However, one would also think that due to his performance this season, the price would not be nearly as steep.
Vinny Cerrato's Best Move as a Redskin
Breaking Burgundy Top Stories
Morning Manny: Quarterback Position ReviewManny Benton reviews the Redskins Quarterback position prior to training camp.
Breaking BurgundyWednesday at 5:00 AM
Could Nate Sudfeld Be The 2018 Redskins QB?One man in the front office had high praise for the sophomore passer.
Breaking BurgundyTuesday at 5:00 AM
When Swearinger Sized Up Redskins Safety WoesThe new starting free safety had his eyes on the Redskins way before he entered free agency.
It's Rob Kelley's Job To Lose At RBContrary to popular belief, Redskins RB Robert Kelley has a strong grip as the team's lead back.
Potential Trade Partners For Matt JonesThere are a few teams that could use another running back in the mix.