Analyzing the TEs...Looking Back at '06

Prior to busting out NFL Fantasy Football 2007, we'll take a look back at TE preseason picks and final rankings for 2006.


Antonio Gates led all tight ends in receiving yardage (924) and touchdowns (9) to comfortably keep his title as "The Best Tight End in Football". Gates combined size, athleticism, and a strong offensive team to contribute to his totals and not disappoint his fantasy owners who may have been concerned about drafting him early. Many preseason fantasy rankings included Crumpler, Shockey, Heap, Cooley, and Gonzalez in the top bunch with Gates...and all finished within reach of Gates. But those who didn't jump up and get Gates may have been the real benefactors with the parity among '06 tight ends. In fact, Chicago's Desmond Clark finished the season ranked as the 7th overall tight end - and was just 3 TDs / 300 receiving yards behind the top spot.

Basically, Gates wasn't the only non-surprise as preseason top ranked tight ends proved their worth by finishing the season at the top of the TE class. Behind Gates, most mags and publications ranked Shockey, Gonzalez, Heap, and Crumpler in or near their top 5...which proved golden for fantasy owners who followed the advice of experts. Contrary to some of the other preseason position predictions, tight ends were an area the experts got right. And with the grouped consistency among tight ends in 2006, there was no reward to those who reached for a tight end in their fantasy draft. Those who took the advice and waited prior to taking a tight end became the wiser. Few stats differentiated the top TE (Gates) and a TE several slots below him...which was not the situation with other skilled positions.

I felt pretty comfortable with my rankings at the the point of being somewhat of a no-brainer. Gates was a stud in a power offense with a huge distracting threat from top running back LaDainian Tomlinson. Each of the top 6 ranked tight ends were receiving leaders on their particular teams in 2005. As expected, they would again dominate their respective passing games in '06. And if you take away a couple of Crumpler's early TDs...then my top six tight ends for 2006 finish the year in the order they were ranked. The preseason ranking of Kellen Winslow Jr. at 8th was probably what set me slightly apart from the rest of the fantasy experts (he finished 9th). Most were scared of Winslow after a couple of injury riddled seasons, but his talent was unmistakable...and if he would have found the endzone a bit more, he may have claimed the top spot with his whopping 89 (EIGHTY NINE) grabs and 875 receiving yards.

With relatively few surprises, 2006 was an easy year to select tight ends for just about anyone. Those who stuck with the expert rankings and forecasts were safe in their fantasy drafts. When compared to how my TE picks finished the season, I'd have to grade my preseason '06 rankings with a solid A. Most of my fellow fantasy experts who went on record with preseason '06 TE rankings also nailed the tight end position fairly closely...and most also made the honor roll with their picks.


NFL Fantasy Tight Ends 2006

Actual 2006 Final Rankings

PreSeason '06 Fantasy Freak Rankings
What Happened?
Antonio Gates
Antonio Gates
Contrary to the thinking of some, Gates is the "Best Tight End in Football"...and was no surprise to finish the season at number one as he led all 2006 TEs in receiving yards (924) and TDs (9)
Crumpler went off early and became a scoring machine (2nd among all '06 TEs in scoring w/ 8 TDs) inside the 20 for the Falcons prior to declining numbers as the season wound down...had I slotted Crumpler at 2nd instead of 5th - and I would have nailed the top 6 fantasy TEs in order of finish...I'll take it!
Jeremy Shockey
Jeremy Shockey plays HARD EVERY PLAY...and if the New York Giants would have played with and finished with the same tenacity, Shockey would have been in the top spot for fantasy TEs rather than 3rd
Tony Gonzalez
Gonzo is like the Energizer Bunny...he just keeps going and going...TG finished 2nd in catches (73) and yardage (900), but his scores were limited at only 5 for the season
Todd Heap
Alge Crumpler
Matching Gonzo's catch total at 73, Todd Heap was able to get into the endzone for an additional score (6)...but Heap's yardage totals were 135 less than Gonzalez - which put him even or slightly lower in the final '06 TE rankings
Chris Cooley
Cooley was consistent and had similar numbers to Heap, but with less receptions (giving Heap the edge since TEs often are granted points for receptions)
Desmond Clark
Clark had 6 scores on just 45 receptions (imagine if Clark was in the lineup on more plays than just a few in the Bear offense with an overzealous Grossman tossing the ball his direction!?)...Jason Witten's injury kept him from the top ten
Kellen Winslow Jr.
I had Smith at 12th...L.J.'s consistency between 2 different QBs (McNabb and Garcia) moved him up a few notches in the final totals
Kellen Winslow Jr.
I ranked Winslow higher (8th) than most every other expert...his 9th place final ranking doesn't quite seem justice considering his whopping 89 (EIGHTY-NINE) receptions to lead all TEs, but Winslow was able to score just 3 times on the season (knocking his final fantasy ranking considerably)...Watson was close to my preseason ranking of 9th, but couldn't quite break into the top 10




*reprinted 2006 final Top Fantasy TE article below


1. Antonio Gates - Gates recertified his title as "The Best Tight End in Football". It took some time for Gates to totally adapt to the San Diego change at quarterback from Drew Brees to Philip Rivers, but Gates' numbers improved as the season progressed to put him on pace to have the top NFL TE numbers by year's end. Gates scored 5 TDs in his final 6 regular season games...with an accumulated 20 grabs for 275 yards and 4 TDs in weeks 12-14. Fantasy owners who drafted Antonio Gates early were rewarded as he put up top 15 caliber wide receiver numbers as a tight end.

2. Alge Crumpler - "Big Alge" was a "Big TD Target" inside the 20 for quarterback Michael Vick. With 6 touchdowns in his first 8 games, Crumpler was key to Atlanta's early victories and seemingly put the Falcons on their way to big things with a jumpstart record of 5-2. In fact, Crumpler had a 4 game pace (weeks 6-9) where he caught 19 balls for 302 yards with 5 TDs! But as the season progressed, Crumpler's numbers declined and so did the Falcons. AG scored just 2 TDs in the 2nd half of the season and the Falcons won just 2 of their final 9 games. Regardless, Alge Crumpler's 1st half performance was enough to boost him to 2nd overall for fantasy TE production in 2006.

3. Jeremy Shockey - Shockey plays offense like Brian Urlacher plays defense. Everytime Shockey gets the ball, he wants to hit someone...and it seems to work for him. On the season, Shockey bulled his way to 7 TDs to rank 3rd in scoring of all tight ends. But like Crumpler, Shockey scored most of his TDs in the first half of the season with 5 in his first 8 games to help lead the Giants to a 6-2 record after starting the season at 1-2. Shockey's total of 7 touchdowns and 600+ yards for the season is still respectable and ranks him 3rd overall at his position, but early season indications appeared Shockey would be on a much more torrid pace for the season. Shockey was unable to score in NYG's final 3 games and sat out week 17 with an injury.

4. Tony Gonzalez - Always a player at TE...Gonzo overcame dominance by Larry Johnson and a Chiefs quarterback change to remain a key factor in the KC offense. Gonzalez put up 900 yards on 73 catches for the season...ranking him 2nd in both categories for tight ends. Although Gonzo was consistent in touches and yardage, the downside to his performance was his lack of TDs - finishing with just 5 for the year.

5. Todd Heap - Heap had a tendency to be questionable on the injury report every single week. But somehow Heap rarely missed time. Similar to several of our top tight ends for 2006, Heap busted out early with 5 TDs in his first 7 games. But also similar to other top TE's this past season, Heap faltered in the second half of the season and scored just one touchdown in his final 9 games. Regardless, Heap scored a respectable 6 touchdowns for the year on 73 catches...but wasn't exactly a scoring machine down the stretch for his fantasy owners..

6. Chris Cooley - Cooley had similar numbers to Todd Heap, but with fewer receptions (57). The main difference with Cooley was that he somewhat spread his scoring throughout the season after going scoreless in his first 5 games.

7. Desmond Clark - With an over-anxious quarterback who wants to always throw the ball in the redzone (when running may make more sense), players like Desmond Clark start to show up on the radar. Of Clark's 45 catches, 6 went for Rex Grossman often looked Clark's direction when he was on the field.

8. L.J. Smith - Smith adjusted to a change at QB from Donovan McNabb to Jeff Garcia and it didn't affect his performance much. L.J. stayed pretty consistent on the season with 50 grabs for 600+ yards and 5 TDs...not great, but good enough (esp. if in a league that requires use of a tight end).

9. Kellen Winslow Jr. - Winslow has arguably the most talent of any wide receiver in the league. In fact, he led all tight ends with 89 (EIGHTY-NINE) receptions! Only five wide receivers caught more balls this past season. Winslow is third in yardage with 875, but made it into the endzone only 3 times...and wasn't able to score in the 2nd half of the season. The Browns never seemed to find their offense in '06, but Winslow held a key role in what they were able to produce.

Top Fantasy Tight Ends 2006



Rec Yards


Antonio Gates




Alge Crumpler
Jeremy Shockey
Tony Gonzalez
Todd Heap

Chris Cooley




Desmond Clark
L.J. Smith
Kellen Winslow Jr.


Send your fantasy questions to



Scout NFL Network Top Stories