Most football people will tell you that you can't truly judge a draft until two or three years after the fact. What may look like a reach may be viewed as a wise move three years down the road and the "can't miss" tag that accompanies some players on draft day becomes "bust" some time later.
Much like mock drafts that precede the draft, giving draft grades immediately after the draft is highly speculatory. Different evaluators will see different things and, in the case of the Vikings, the differences of opinion couldn't be more across the board.
The one thing pretty much everyone agrees on is that Chad Greenway was the right pick at No. 17 for the Vikings in the first round -- a need matched with a player's approximate draft value. But after that, it gets pretty dicey.
Pete Prisco of NFL.com loved the Vikings' draft -- giving a draft grade of B+. That represented the highest grade of any team in the NFC North and only seven teams were given a higher draft grade than that.
The Sporting News War Room gave the Vikings a good grade on Greenway and Cedric Griffin, but called Ryan Cook a "surprise pick" that they had figured as a fifth- or sixth-round selection. They also thought the Vikings gave up too much for Tarvaris Jackson.
Mel Kiper gave the Vikings a C+ draft grade -- only 11 teams got a worse score -- but he said much of the draft hinged on Jackson. Both he and draft-day analyst Ron Jaworski raved about Jackson's potential, but he too felt that the Vikings may have pulled the trigger a little early on making the deal.
Then there is Nolan Nawrocki from Pro Football Weekly. To say he hated the draft is an understatement. He gave the Vikings a D- for the draft -- by far the worst grade of any team. How bad was it? No other team got a grade worse than a C-. He was especially critical of the Jackson pick, calling it "an embarrassment in the second round."
As most football people will tell you, a draft can't truly be analyzed until a couple of years out, but the opinions on the Vikings' draft are as divergent as they can be. We'll have to check back in a couple of years to see who was right and who was wrong.
The Reviews Are In
Viking Update Top Stories
Smith misses again; stage set for Harris?As Harrison Smith missed his third practice this week with an ankle injury, it appears safety Anthony Harris could be getting the third start of his career.
Viking Update9:40 AM
Holler: Who blinks first with Peterson?Social media pulled out its stereotypical fangs about noon Wednesday when Adrian Peterson opted to speak to the local media. The problem with the venom is that the antidote is more…
Viking Update5:21 AM
Peterson discusses rehab, defying timetableAll the talk about Adrian Peterson on Wednesday was whether the Vikings would win enough to make his return sensible. But, he's spent almost three months pushing for that to happen…
Viking Update4:16 AM
VIDEO: Zimmer tired of talking about his eyeMinnesota Vikings coach Mike Zimmer wasn't in the mood to discuss his ailing eye anymore, wanting to keep the focus on correcting mistakes and trying to beat Jacksonville.
Viking UpdateYesterday at 3:52 PM
VIDEO: Bradford on offensive strugglesMinnesota Vikings QB Sam Bradford talks about getting Mike Zimmer back and the offensive problems that have plagued the team.
Viking UpdateYesterday at 3:45 PM